Re:5 Months After Switching to Colemak
by christiangenco on Thursday September 12, 2013 @03:13AM
(#6372537)
Fair point on travel distance. I suppose I need to be experiencing some kind of tendinitis for the switch to become worthwhile.
Forgot part 4 of my keyboard remapping: caps lock + another key is interpreted as control, but just tapping caps lock is escape.
All I really need now is a shorter space bar so I can more comfortably hit ctrl/cmd with my thumbs and I'll be in keyboard nirvana. Total missed opportunity by Atwood with his CODE keyboard.
Re:5 Months After Switching to Colemak
by MrGando on Thursday September 12, 2013 @08:27AM
(#6373564)
In my case, I was experiencing pre-tendinitis symptoms (know them well as a piano player). All of those where gone after switching to Colemak. My advice, is to switch before you start experiencing those symptoms.
Cheers!
That hasn't been my experience on Dvorak, QWERTY comes back almost instantly. It was harder when I had just learned Dvorak but since I, like you, have to use QWERTY keyboards often the situation quickly improved (in much less time than it took to learn Dvorak).
> The primary argument for Colemak is that it reduces finger travel distance from the home row. But my fingers don't naturally fall precisely in a line
Travel distance looks more like E[||key1 position - key2 position||] not E[||key position - resting position||] when you're writing a big chunk of text, so the resting position of your fingers is not very important for the purposes of minimizing wrist strain. Anecdotally, the difference in wrist strain isn't remotely subtle between the two layouts. Of course, I don't usually type enough to get sore, but I can certainly feel the tendons move through my wrist, and they move a great deal more when I'm using QWERTY.
"This is a test sentence" leaves the home row once on Dvorak and 13 times on QWERTY, but the Dvorak advantage for this sentence would be just as good if you permuted the key rows so that 18/19 of the keypresses landed on, say, the top row.
I prefer mapping caps lock to ctrl since it makes both vim and emacs easy (I use ctrl-C in place of esc in vim, so for it has worked for everything but block replacement).