Re:The Pernicious Myth that You Don't Need College to Be an ...
by mindcrime on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:22PM
(#6370226)
A(nother) problem with this discussion, is that Wadhwa and others seem to create a dichotomy where you either:
1. Graduate from a University with a B.S
or
2. Are an uneducated bum with no career prospects.
But there's a huge continuum between those poles. What about people with Associate degrees? Or people who start their Bachelors program, almost finish, and then drop out? Or people who start their Bachelors program, after having earned one Associate degree, then drop out, then go on to earn 2 more Associate degrees? (Yeah, that one happens, that was my story).
Of course, while I disagree with Wadhwa on a number of things, I don't entirely disagree with his notion that finishing school is important for most people, in most situations. But I think you have to be willing to accept that it's not the right path for everybody, in every situation.
I dropped out while still a junior, and my career has worked out pretty well. But I also somehow collected 3 Associate degrees over the years as well, and I went into a field (software development) that is known for being less focused on "paper credentials". So my point certainly isn't that everybody should do what I did, but just to say that these things are always judgment calls and that some people are well served by dropping out.
As for the entrepreneurship part... I've founded a startup, but it's undetermined as of yet if we'll be one of the successes or not. But I think it's interesting that some people[1] are mentioning us in the same breath as companies like Asana now, even though they were started by Facebook alums and people from Google and Microsoft, while we were founded by a college dropout with no connections or money to speak of. We may not succeed, but we've at least managed to fight out way into the game to some extent.
1. Graduate from a University with a B.S
or
2. Are an uneducated bum with no career prospects.
But there's a huge continuum between those poles. What about people with Associate degrees? Or people who start their Bachelors program, almost finish, and then drop out? Or people who start their Bachelors program, after having earned one Associate degree, then drop out, then go on to earn 2 more Associate degrees? (Yeah, that one happens, that was my story).
Of course, while I disagree with Wadhwa on a number of things, I don't entirely disagree with his notion that finishing school is important for most people, in most situations. But I think you have to be willing to accept that it's not the right path for everybody, in every situation.
I dropped out while still a junior, and my career has worked out pretty well. But I also somehow collected 3 Associate degrees over the years as well, and I went into a field (software development) that is known for being less focused on "paper credentials". So my point certainly isn't that everybody should do what I did, but just to say that these things are always judgment calls and that some people are well served by dropping out.
As for the entrepreneurship part... I've founded a startup, but it's undetermined as of yet if we'll be one of the successes or not. But I think it's interesting that some people[1] are mentioning us in the same breath as companies like Asana now, even though they were started by Facebook alums and people from Google and Microsoft, while we were founded by a college dropout with no connections or money to speak of. We may not succeed, but we've at least managed to fight out way into the game to some extent.
[1]: http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2013/09/04/companies...