News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by gaius on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:28PM (#6369807)
The question is really, what is a government for? If it is not to look out for the best interests of citizens, why are they paying its taxes snd obeying its laws? It is not protectionism at all to level the playing field, America was built on immigration, but the H1B is indentured servitude.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by WalterBright on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:00PM (#6370071)
Preventing the importation of labor is not going to solve the problem. All it does is cause the company to move operations offshore. If that was made illegal, then foreign owned companies would then outcompete domestic companies. I suppose you could then put a tariff wall around the country, but historically that hasn't worked out well (Smoot-Hawley).

The thing is, you cannot wish or legislate away the existence of skilled labor from outside the country.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by zpk on Thursday September 12, 2013 @09:40AM (#6373891)
" All it does is cause the company to move operations offshore."

If this worked, then we wouldn't be having this visa discussion.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by hownottowrite on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @06:28PM (#6370571)
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by gaius on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:30PM (#6370267)
Who said anything about prevention? I said a level playing field.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by Jayschwa on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:43PM (#6369931)
> If it is not to look out for the best interests of citizens, why are they paying taxes?

It's in the best interest of the person who has to compete with the immigrant, but it's not in the best interest of anyone else - citizen or otherwise. Immigration benefits other citizens in the form of cheaper products and services. Immigration also benefits the immigrant (if it didn't, they wouldn't be trying to get in).

This issue is somewhat personal for me because I have foreign friends who are good engineers and would like to work here, but can't because of the regulations.

> It is not protectionism at all to level the playing field

This isn't leveling the playing field, this is refusing to let other (potentially better) players on the field because we have less capable players (who happened to be here first).

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:53PM (#6370028)
I mean no disrespect, but my government's role is to protect its citizens, not perspective immigrants.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by vinceguidry on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @07:56PM (#6371041)
Only in your imagination. Government's real role is to protect the people with money. Always has been.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @10:38PM (#6371719)
I'm old, yet not old enough to be that bitter and/or cynical.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by vinceguidry on Thursday September 12, 2013 @12:26AM (#6372054)
I don't consider myself bitter or cynical. Just realistic. Who has the most influence in Washington? What do they use that influence for? In the middle of all that whirlwind of money in Washington, how much mind space do you think they really give to their constituents when it's not an election year?

I'm acquainted with a state Senator. He's a well meaning guy, but he acknowledges just what a corrupting effect the truckloads of money has on national politics.

I've read that there are over 10,000 pages to Obamacare. Who wrote all that? How much insight into the health care field does it take to put in so much detail? Who else could have possibly written it other than the health care field itself?

We talk about regulatory capture like it's some horrific thing akin to Stalinism. But it's reality, today, in every single economic field that's more complex than hairdressing. How could we possibly provide meaningful oversight over the passing of a bill that fills a shelf? The only thing we can do is debate meaningless talking points that don't address the critical reality. Industries are regulating themselves, and we're just letting them frame the discussion while they sell out the public under our very noses.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by nknighthb on Thursday September 12, 2013 @11:03PM (#6378325)
> I've read that there are over 10,000 pages to Obamacare.

The widely-available bill[1], which takes all of five seconds to find with Google, is 906 pages with legislative (huge margins) formatting. Consider not getting your "facts" from people with an axe to grind.

http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-111hr3590enr/pdf/BILLS-11...

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by toomuchtodo on Thursday September 12, 2013 @12:19PM (#6375024)
The only solution is complete and utter transparency.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by the_watcher on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:32AM (#6372408)
prospective and perspective mean two very different things.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by gaius on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:50PM (#6370005)
Not true, unless said "better" players have Green Cards. And there is already a process for that.

The only purpose of H1B the legal construct is to erode workers rights.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by snowwrestler on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:31PM (#6370275)
So the problem is H1B process specifically? You'd support a skilled worker immigration program if it used the Green Card process instead?
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by gaius on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:41PM (#6370318)
Correct. Let's see if big corps are so keen truly on merit.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by the_watcher on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:32AM (#6372411)
They are.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by gaius on Thursday September 12, 2013 @11:01AM (#6374476)
Pay figures suggest otherwise. If someone truly is a) a world-class expert and b) desperately needed, you would see H1B pay outstrip that of locals, and fair enough. But in fact you see that IT wages across the board have been stagnant since the dot-com crash, allowing for inflation. That is pretty strong evidence there is no shortage and may already be a glut.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by staccatomeasure on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @06:36PM (#6370613)
I would argue it's very unclear if it is in the best interest of everyone else.

Immigrants send money home (out of our economy). Companies may produce more/cheaper, resulting in possibly lower prices. But maybe they just spend the extra revenue lobbying Congress for preferential treatment. Maybe it results in more money shipped offshore to tax havens.

And if indeed immigrants are just cheaper replacements for their American counterparts, it takes away money (which, remember, is equivalent to speech) from citizens of this country.