News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by tn13 on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:25PM (#6369784)
If American government is serious about protecting the interests of American workforce; implement the following simple rule.

1. Let H1B be independent of the employer. Current H1B rules are modern day equivalent of bonded labor. Let a person obtain H1B from the employer for the first time, after that make it independent of the employer. For example a person on H1B may resign on day 1 and simply join another American company.

Remove all the nonsense about salary limits and so on.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by abhiv on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @06:11PM (#6370481)
This already exists as a practical matter. According to current rules (specifically, the AC21 act), H-1B workers can start working at a new employer as soon an H-1B transfer application is filed by their new company. There is no need to even wait for the application to be approved. Applications to transfer H-1B visa are not subject to the cap, so there isn't that issue either.

H-1B employees are currently quite mobile. I have many friends who've switched jobs repeatedly during their H-1B period because it's so easy to transfer the visa. I honestly don't know where this whole "indentured servitude" idea comes from.

The part of the system that's fubared is the green card process, which can stretch for up to 10 years if you're from India or China. During a part of that time (not the entire duration), you can't switch jobs unless you want the green card process to be restarted, which affects mobility. But that is not related to the H-1B, and the solution to that is to fix the green card process.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by dclusin on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @06:23PM (#6370542)
Additionally not all H1B's are underpaid. I'm currently in the minority on the engineering team, being one of the few American citizens actually born in America. From discussions with my peers from India they don't make that much less than me. The cost of immigration is factored into their salary of course, but for the most part are on par with market wages.

But the company was also founded by immigrants so this may be an exception rather than the rule.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by tn13 on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @06:36PM (#6370618)
There is definitely an underbelly for software industry and we do not know how it function. For example I have a friend who has H1B but no job and is working for cash at a superstore for $40 a day.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by HistoryInAction on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @07:10PM (#6370791)
Comprehensive immigration reform, at least the Senate bill, will implement green card sponsorship portability, which will fix this problem.

You're completely right that H-1B portability was implemented, which happened in 2008 with the America COMPETES Act.

The indentured servitude view is lingering, but it's also still unfortunately valid when it comes to the H-1B dual-intent EB-2/3 green card applications, as many try to follow that pathway.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:43PM (#6369925)
Even simpler would just be eliminating most economic non-visitor, non-treaty-based visa categories in favor of a single, category for all non-prohibited entrants who either are not qualified for a family, political (refugee, victimization-based, etc.), etc. visa, or who are qualified for such a visa in a category for which there is a waiting list to enter and remain prior to moving to the head of the list, which carries a substantial basic annual fee and requires supplemental income tax on any wages income earned in the US during the period they are present on the visa.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by jacalata on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:53PM (#6370030)
I'm already paying you for social security and medicare that I will probably never be eligible to benefit from, and you want me to pay extra 'fuck you' taxes as well? Thanks but no thanks.

Aside from that, this wouldn't be simple at all because changing the visas available would in many cases involve renegotiating the deals that they made with other countries that got those visas created in the first place. Sure, it would likely be possible to tell all the other countries to get stuffed, but good luck getting US citizens a visa to travel anywhere if you keep doing that.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:06PM (#6370108)
> I'm already paying you for social security and medicare that I will probably never be eligible to benefit from, and you want me to pay extra 'fuck you' taxes as well?

This was in response to a suggestion about what the government would do if it was interested in serving its citizens. If you would be paying the fees, serving you is very much not the point.

Though I'll point out that, by moving from employee sponsorship and charges (and pay limits, etc.) on employers for things like H-1B to charges to the prospective entrant, it means that the entrant has substantially more freedom (and potentially greater net income after charges, too, since instead of the employer paying a fee and dealing with wage limits, the employee pays a flat fee and a share of income, but isn't burdened by salary limits.)

> Aside from that, this wouldn't be simple at all because changing the visas available would in many cases involve renegotiating the deals that they made with other countries that got those visas created in the first place.

By definition, changing the non-treaty visas, as I specified, would not require that, and many economic visas (including the H-1B) are not treaty-based.

Obviously treaty-based econonmic visas like the H-1B1 (Singapore or Chile), TN/TD (NAFTA), E-1/E-2 (Treaty Trader/Treaty Investor) etc. are a separate issue, but at least in theory the government is serving citizens interests with those because of the reciprocal benefit US citizens have with regard to economic entry to the countries involved.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by jacalata on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:41PM (#6370317)
Sorry - I missed the 'non treaty' mention in your post. Doesn't that pretty much mean H1Bs (and maybe all the investor visas)? While I agree that it would increase employee freedom to have them bear the cost and not be tied to the company, I doubt that it would end up with increasing income - in theory, all the Silicon Vally companies are already paying as much as they can to attract talent.

edit: actually, there is of course also O, L, P and I. I'm not sure how much you'd gain by folding them into a single category - there's very little relationship between,e eg, whether Nadal should be here for the US Open and how many programmers should be coming here. L perhaps has some overlap.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @06:06PM (#6370456)
> Sorry - I missed the 'non treaty' mention in your post. Doesn't that pretty much mean H1Bs (and maybe all the investor visas)?

> edit: actually, there is of course also O, L, P and I.

And the immigrant E series Employment-related ones. There's a few others that might fit into the general description I laid out depending on exactly where you draw the line on transitory (non-immigrant H-2A, for instance, could be argued either way.)

(I specify immigrant/non-immigrant, because there's a handful of categories designations used for both immigrant and non-immigrant classes where the use between the two classes has no real relationship; E is one of these.)

> I'm not sure how much you'd gain by folding them into a single category - there's very little relationship between,e eg, whether Nadal should be here for the US Open and how many programmers should be coming here.

"How many" isn't really an issue, since the whole idea of folding it into one class is that its a class that is open to any non-banned entrant and isn't numerically limited, instead its open-for-pay.

Anyhow, I'd think Nadal for the US Open be a non-immigrant B-1, which is transitory by any reasonable definition, and certainly isn't in the scope of what I was proposing.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by sologoub on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:45PM (#6369950)
You'd have to include some form of protection for the employer on the expenses associated with H1B process, otherwise it's not really worth the risk - imagine if you paid say $15k for the filing and waited 6 months. Then the person you hired comes in and asks for a 20% raise or he/she walks on day 1.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by tn13 on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:13PM (#6370155)
No. Employer should not get any protection at all. That is the whole point. Consider the scenario. 1. You hire a person for 100k, file H1B for her. On the first day of her job she asks for 20% raise. 2. You say "you are fired" to her. There are two cases here: - She walks out searching for a job. She does not find a job which pays here more than 100k, she comes back to you and beg to be taken back. (Remember that she is likely to know her self worth and hence will not leave the job in first place if she knows that no one else can pay her more than 100k).

- She walks out searching for a job, she finds a job that pays 120k. This means you hired her because you found her "cheaper" than American counterparts. So you are penalized. Hence next time you wont hire a employee worth $120k for $100k. You will prefer a $120k American girl over $100k Indian girl.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by sologoub on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @07:23PM (#6370878)
Well, if you want to kill the H1B program completely, sure.

However, if the idea is to have it survive and, dare I say it, be used for the beneficial purpose of bringing vital new blood to the country's workforce instead of being a cheap source of labor, then employers need strong incentive to spend the money needed to get someone into US without fear that they will simply walk off.

It's not what I want as a US employee (my self-interest is to have as few people of the same skill as possible in order to command highest salary), but it is something that would be needed in order to get some sort of a chance at having such rules pass.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:07PM (#6370118)
> You'd have to include some form of protection for the employer on the expenses associated with H1B process, otherwise it's not really worth the risk

I thought increasing the risk in the H-1B process (and thus making not choosing that over spending resources retraining domestic workers) was exactly the point of the suggestion.

Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by DamnYuppie on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:52PM (#6370012)
Why are we giving protection to the employer? Have employers in this country shown they care about employees except for sound bites?
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by jacalata on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:55PM (#6370044)
If you gave the employers some kind of protection for training outlays, they might bother to train locals instead of hold out for unicorns to land in the factory fully trained.
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:46PM (#6370348)
So now the government needs to protect incompetent HR managers and management because they have unrealistic expectations towards hiring?
Re:Companies lay off thousands, then demand immigration refo... by jacalata on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:57PM (#6370412)
No, they need to provide incentives to people who are able to make a difference and currently aren't. Like they give tax credits for hiring veterans, and other similar programs to manipulate the behaviour of employers for the benefit of potential employees.