News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by crazygringo on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @05:52PM (#6363771)
> "Instead, the data factories get free labor. They distribute what seem like useful services to the world, things like YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Etsy, or Kickstarter. ...earn tons of money for the tech giants without forcing them to do much work. That money stays concentrated around the data factories and their limited staff instead of distributing it like traditional factories."

What? In what universe do the employees at YouTube or Facebook or Etsy "not do much work"? How do these only "seem" like useful services -- is somebody saying they're not? How do traditional factories "distribute money"? If Twitter is getting "free labor" please tell me how, so I can get in on it too.

Sure, there's a shift towards concentration of wealth, but paragraphs like the above one make zero sense.

Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @06:48PM (#6364105)
The idea is that YouTube doesn't do much work when compared with the people who actually make and upload all the videos.

Which is a perfectly valid criticism. In absolute numbers, the amount of hours collectively put in by YouTube users to create content is much larger than the number put in by YouTube/Google employees to serve that content.

Right now, however, there is basically very little actual negotiation between the platform provider and the content creator. The former gets the vast majority of all revenue; the latter mostly works for free. We consumers enjoy our free, ad-supported video site, but YouTube might as well just be the new record company (especially with the all the take-downs and region restrictions!).

Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by jmillikin on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @07:15PM (#6364254)

  > Right now, however, there is basically very little
  > actual negotiation between the platform provider and the
  > content creator. The former gets the vast majority of
  > all revenue; the latter mostly works for free. We
  > consumers enjoy our free, ad-supported video site
The uploader decides whether a particular video has ads or not. According to http://allthingsd.com/20130304/youtubes-show-me-the-money-pr... YouTube takes a 45% cut, which means the content creator ends up with the majority of the ad revenue.
Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @07:21PM (#6364280)
I stand corrected, downvote away.
Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @12:39AM (#6365544)
You get a better split with the mob. 45%? Wow.
Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by vdaniuk on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:47AM (#6366161)
Every content creator is free to roll out his own architecture of streaming video, strike ad deals and get 100% of the income.

Comparing Youtube to the mob is not a valid argument.

Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @12:06PM (#6368020)
I'd argue Android's ecosystem and investment is enormous compared to Youtube, and they take a smaller cut from apps/in-app purchases than Youtube.

There's just something slimy about taking that much of a cut from someone's work. Its disgusting.

Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by jmillikin on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:10PM (#6370142)

  > I'd argue Android's ecosystem and investment is
  > enormous compared to Youtube, and they take a smaller
  > cut from apps/in-app purchases than Youtube.
You can do some quick back-of-the-envelope calculations on the storage and bandwidth requirements of video and applications. It's very expensive to process, store, and serve video at YouTube's scale. See http://www.youtube.com/yt/press/statistics.html for some numbers.

  > There's just something slimy about taking that much of
  > a cut from someone's work. Its disgusting.
When media hosting sites take half of revenue, it's not out of sheer greed. Most of that money goes right into paying for bandwidth and compute to keep the service running. For example, iTunes Music is believed to have profit margins in the low single digits -- based on Apple's financial statements, it's barely break-even. Apple's App Store is much more profitable, despite taking only 30% of revenue.
Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by jmillikin on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @02:11AM (#6365799)
That sort of split seems to be fairly typical of user-generated content sites. For example, Amazon takes 65% of revenue from self-published Kindle titles, and Apple takes around 55% from music sold in iTunes[1].

[1] http://www.innojazz.com/2013/03/revenue-split-of-itunes-albu...

Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @12:07PM (#6368033)
Just because its typical doesn't mean its fair nor right.

Also, next time through a disclaimer in that you work for Google.

Re:The Data Factory – How Your Free Labor Lets Tech Giants G... by jmillikin on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @04:51PM (#6370008)

  > Also, next time through a disclaimer in that you work for Google.
I already state that in my profile. People who constantly name-drop their employer in their posts are obnoxious.