News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why U.S. News' college rankings hurt students by rayiner on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @03:58PM (#6362949)
I agree with the general proposition that the rankings hurt college students, particularly because schools raise tuition in order to be able to afford more merit aid, but I find some of the comments to be tropes:

"1. College rankings hurt low and middle-income students. "

It's hard to argue why offering aid on the basis of merit as opposed to need is a bad thing.

"2. The rankings ignore job prospects."

True, but mostly irrelevant. The rankings are broadly correlated with job prospects.

"3. The rankings don't care about learning outcomes."

College isn't about learning, and it's not clear there is much difference between colleges in this regard anyway. You don't go to Harvard because you think it'll teach you better than Penn State. You do it to associate with the other people who got into Harvard.

"4. U.S. News runs a beauty pageant."

The side-effect of the beauty pageant is that it tends to echo preconceived notions hiring managers already have. Arguably it does a huge disservice to say drive students away from Yale on the basis of a bunch of things like "learning outcomes" that nobody else cares about.

"5. College rankings fuel ever greater college costs.'

This is the real takeaway point. Overhead per student is a major component of the rankings, and it helps fuel the ridiculous construction craze that's happening with universities right now.

There are no comments on this comment yet.