Re:University Rankings are Awful. Can We Stop Doing the Same...
by auctiontheory on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @01:28PM
(#6361497)
You have missed the entire point of the article. Arbitrarily quantifying essentially qualitative measures is misleading (bordering on dishonest) and potentially harmful, when these made-up numbers are then used to influence major decisions.
E.g. these bogus college rankings are used to set immigration and other government policy in many countries: http://www.theguardian.com/higher-education-network/blog/201...
The more operations you perform on these made-up numbers, like the "combination" you mention, the more authentic they might seem. But the result of averaging a bunch of made-up numbers is just as meaningless, if not more so.
I've found that some colleges have a reputation centered around specializations, for example biotech, compsci, civil engineering, and so forth. Prospective students make decisions based on this reputation, and it's not difficult to assign a number to that. Whether reputation means anything qualitative is something else entirely, though.
More relevant, though, is that students also use a variety of other factors in their decision making. Cost and relative location (ie: distance from home of closest family, distance to place of work after graduating) are high-priority factors, meanwhile student body composition (ie: asian vs white) is another.
My point is that companies and people don't make decisions based on a single and opaque number, it's just one of many variables in determining where to go and what to do.
The factors I listed above can have numeric values assigned to them, and a single metric can be derived from a combination of these numbers, however that's still somewhat opaque.
It may be unfair to assign a number to an entire country, but that doesn't diminish its value. It would be unwise to use a single metric as input for decision making, and again that doesn't diminish the value of that metric. It's just another metric.