Re:Why cards are the future of the web
by TuringTest on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:14AM
(#6352738)
Personally I think the "fluid" responsive design for article snippets is a mistake; but then I hate multi-column feed designs, so that may be just a personal preference.
Apple got it right with the iPhone menu structure, which was inspired by the iPod (maybe they nailed it because it was not card-based). There, columns always maintain the same positional relation (there are menus to the "left" and sub-menus to the "right"), so you can always remember by muscle-memory where a particular item is located relative to the others. Re-flowing similar items breaks those relations.
Responsive pages make sense when the side columns are used for side content (i.e. "aside" tags, headers and footers, navigation...) - there, placing the sub-content above or below the main content to show it on a narrow screen is not a problem, since the moved card was subordinate to the main article anyway.
Apple got it right with the iPhone menu structure, which was inspired by the iPod (maybe they nailed it because it was not card-based). There, columns always maintain the same positional relation (there are menus to the "left" and sub-menus to the "right"), so you can always remember by muscle-memory where a particular item is located relative to the others. Re-flowing similar items breaks those relations.
Responsive pages make sense when the side columns are used for side content (i.e. "aside" tags, headers and footers, navigation...) - there, placing the sub-content above or below the main content to show it on a narrow screen is not a problem, since the moved card was subordinate to the main article anyway.