News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Norman Borlaug by contingencies on Monday September 09, 2013 @02:05AM (#6352082)
We are soon past the need for genetic diversity. That is just a word for 'random crap we found when civilization began'. We're way past that

I'm not going to comment on the biology/GM side specifically, but there are many scenarios in history where man thought he had dominated nature and got his ass handed to him. Often, entire civilizations descended in to chaos and completely disappeared. Agricultural examples would be the Maya, Angkor, etc. Others are hanging on dimly, like Haiti. Nuclear catastrophes would be another category. Some say the significant destruction of recent earthquakes in western China result from the mega-dam project. Then there's climate change.

You have to zoom out sometimes to see these things: don't blindly put faith in technology, it's not the answer to everything. Sometimes, re-orienting your thinking to be closer to the natural order of things is faster and more effective than trying to out-engineer reality. Biology is no exception.

Re:Norman Borlaug by JoeAltmaier on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:55AM (#6353812)
Now, lets not compare 18th century science with what we have today. Now we understand the systems approach, the nature of life and DNA, we actually construct new plants and creatures routinely, and on and on.

To say "ancient man was arrogant; modern man is arrogant; we'll make the same mistakes" is silly.

Re:Norman Borlaug by contingencies on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:58AM (#6358245)
lets not compare 18th century science with what we have today

My point precisely! I was comparing the human situation, and explaining the difference in philosophy. You on the other hand seem to be keen to expound the wonders of today's technology. My point is that it's not that great, even if it's better than the 18th century, and nature still rules over us with little remorse. Becoming arrogant again about our doings, we shall yet again be put in our place ... history makes this clear. But with what damage to millions of years of biology?

Re:Norman Borlaug by JoeAltmaier on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:04PM (#6377305)
History makes that clear? No, history's lessons are largely moot in this brave new world. If we are bitten, it will be by entirely different things, and probably by human foibles. Like FUD about GMO etc. Not logical, but we will have to deal with it.