I'd say the more important thing is that we not trust any one single person (or corporation). Everything needs to be open, and everything needs to be studied and verified by independent authorities.
This also applies to how you implement your security. You want two person controls for everything, and separation of roles --- those people who can bypass file access controls had better not also be able to wipe log records. The NSA is relearning that lesson the hard way as they try to figure out what records Snowden might have leaked --- apparently Snowden had the ability to impersonate other users, as well as wipe the log records which were _hopefully_ being made when person A uses an "su"-like command to impersonate person B.
After all, when someone stands up to give a suggestion at a standards meeting, or when someone goes through the hiring process to be one of your sysadmins, they won't be wearing a sign saying, "I do a huge amount of consultant work with the NSA and I have Top Secret/SCI/POLY clearance". Neither will job applicants have signs saying, "I'm getting paid by the Chinese MSS", or "I'm here to steal your SSL private keys".
Thanks for all the details on the process tytso, not to mention your work for all these years.
While an argument that in the recent years the pendulum has gone way out into subverting is valid this has not always been the case. They just cannot make USG secure without giving some of that security to everyone. And they cannot weaken everyone's security without endangering themselves.
Of course for now US doesn't have global adversary (that they know of). But with the world moving from sole superpower towards multiple power center this may not be the case for long. And then it will swing in the other direction again.
Just wait for an real cyber attack through one of their backdoors to happen and then you will have them working full steam ahead towards security.
Btw - one of the other things about the extremely potent NSA that are not mentioned at all - if you are a smart adversary then you should just infiltrate NSA and let them do the heavy lifting and have the needed information for the cheap.
The NSA have shown that they, unsurprisingly, have some ability in this area. The trick is surely to discern constructive and destructive contributions.
Brings up an interesting point. Going forward should it be disqualifying to be currently working for the NSA to be on one of these committees? To have formerly worked for them? To done a lot of consulting? To have done any consulting? To have ever had a security clearance?
Witchhunts have a deservedly negative connotation, but what if you are actually surrounded by witches?