News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by derefr on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:04PM (#6342339)
> No, their official response is to suggest that encrypting your communications makes you indistinguishable (at their end) from those who encrypt for criminal activity.

Good way to put it. An analogy that might help this stick in your mind: encrypting your communications is like walking around downtown in black clothes and a face-covering balaclava. You might not be doing anything wrong--but if someone in the same area robs a convenience store, the police won't be able to tell that you aren't them, and they'll have to at least stop you and search you for stolen goods before they can let you go.

Interestingly, just asking you to take off the mask (i.e. knowing that the source and destination headers on the packets are both local) isn't enough; they don't know what the face of the guy who robbed the store looks like under his mask, so knowing what you look like under yours won't tell them whether you're him or not. (Likewise, they don't know that the chinese hackers they're trying to infiltrate aren't using Tor with a US exit node, so they can't trust US-to-US traffic to be, well, US traffic.)

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by antsar on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:23PM (#6342462)
I would also add that using encryption online is much more of a norm than walking around downtown in black clothes and a face-covering balaclava. While both activities are perfectly legal and acceptable, the former is performed by millions on a daily basis and is essential to the successful continuity of businesses and personal lives.

That is to say the likelihood of a random encrypted message on the internet being malicious is infinitely smaller than the likelihood of a person wearing all black with a facemask in the vicinity of a crime perpetrated by someone also wearing all black with a facemask.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by stefantalpalaru on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:15PM (#6342419)
> encrypting your communications is like walking around downtown in black clothes and a face-covering balaclava

No, it's like walking around clothed when most people are naked. You may have legitimate reasons to cover your body, but because you're part of a minority you stand out.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:25PM (#6342476)
Well, you may have legit reasons to wear a balaclava. You may have a facial scar which you don't want people seeing. You may be doing a film for a director friend of yours. It may be freaking cold outside.

Either way changing the labels you use doesn't significantly change the point.