News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by rayiner on Friday September 06, 2013 @03:44PM (#6342244)
We don't know how much traffic the NSA actually decrypts, just that it has the capability to do so.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by HarryHirsch on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:13PM (#6342406)
But we know about COINTELPRO, and we know that Egdar Hoover had a bag of dirt on everyone that mattered.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by juhanima on Friday September 06, 2013 @05:27PM (#6342778)
Goes to show that if you have the means, you'll come up with the ends, eventually. I agree, a very good point.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by dllthomas on Saturday September 07, 2013 @12:29AM (#6343983)
Hammers and nails, to some degree...
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by totalforge on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:44PM (#6342570)
Hm, good point, the NSA as the new old FBI.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by Seigmen on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:05PM (#6342344)
That doesn't mean we should trust trust them not to decrypt the trafic though.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:22PM (#6342455)
Just like we shouldn't have to trust the cops not to bust my door down, right?

It sounds snarky but it cuts to the core of the peoples' relationship with government. How much do you trust the government? How much can you trust the government?

That's why libertarians are generally logically consistent when they oppose the NSA, and entitlement programs, and giant government services, etc., because they're the ones who will tell you that a government big enough to give you $FOO is big enough to take it away from everyone else.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by etherael on Saturday September 07, 2013 @11:19AM (#6345295)
> Just like we shouldn't have to trust the cops not to bust my door down, right?

Sure, if it were possible to stop the government from doing anything at all I would be in favour of that, letalone obviously positive things like not spying on everybody or busting down their doors. Of course, there are no doors that require more energy than that available in the universe to forcibly enter. That's not the case for cryptography so it makes sense to exploit that. What am I missing here?

> It sounds snarky but it cuts to the core of the peoples' relationship with government. How much do you trust the government? How much can you trust the government?

This sounds like it is supposed to be some kind of profound question, but the answer is consistent and obvious in both cases, not at all.

> That's why libertarians are generally logically consistent when they oppose the NSA, and entitlement programs, and giant government services, etc., because they're the ones who will tell you that a government big enough to give you $FOO is big enough to take it away from everyone else.

Sure, I'd tell you that, I don't see why it's inconsistent to believe that and simultaneously want to dismantle the government? Isn't it actually pretty much the only logically consistent position?

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Saturday September 07, 2013 @02:19PM (#6345945)
> Sure, I'd tell you that, I don't see why it's inconsistent to believe that and simultaneously want to dismantle the government? Isn't it actually pretty much the only logically consistent position?

It is one logically consistent position, yes.

I happen to disagree that it is the only logically consistent position, which is one reason I've been poking so hard at the notion that people need to examine under what logical basis government operates at all before they go 'rah rah government bad!'.

Much like a corporation is the legal stand-in for the will of the collective shareholders, a government is the societal stand-in for the will of the people at large.

A society that tries to maintain no government, or very limited government, is at an unstable point. In the best case it will collapse from internal conflict but be left alone from there (e.g. Somalia, tribal areas of Afghanistan/Pakistan). In the normal case the society will simply be eventually overrun by those who choose to organize (e.g. USA vs. the Native Americans, Hitler vs. the appeasers), but a government will spring up again one way or another.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by etherael on Saturday September 07, 2013 @02:55PM (#6346100)
> I happen to disagree that it is the only logically consistent position

When I say it's a logically consistent position, what I mean to imply by that is for people who think that government is an abomination, it is logically consistent for them to hope for the dismantling thereof. You, who most decidedly do not think that government is an abomination, as a lawyer, are logically consistent in thinking that it should not be dismantled.

> Much like a corporation is the legal stand-in for the will of the collective shareholders, a government is the societal stand-in for the will of the people at large.

Except that it most clearly is not.

> A society that tries to maintain no government, or very limited government, is at an unstable point. In the best case it will collapse from internal conflict but be left alone from there (e.g. Somalia, tribal areas of Afghanistan/Pakistan). In the normal case the society will simply be eventually overrun by those who choose to organize (e.g. USA vs. the Native Americans, Hitler vs. the appeasers), but a government will spring up again one way or another.

That's a normalcy bias, there have been many points throughout history with no centralised productivity extracting parasitic force initiating agency. In fact, the variant we have now with extremely high direct taxation on the incomes of almost all productive activity within a society is the historical anathema. Not only that, but this fails to take into account the methods of control the state actually uses to exercise control on its population, and that currency control was recently removed from their hands.

Agorism becomes a very real threat under these circumstances

As a nash equilibrium, an involuntary centralised productivity extracting parasitic force initiating agency is not at all stable. It stands to reason that it will only be able to maintain control by either force or fraud. Right now they're going with fraud, from the amount of discontent I see with the political state of the world I don't know how much longer it will last until they devolve to force.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Saturday September 07, 2013 @06:30PM (#6346887)
I'm not actually a lawyer, though I suppose I do sometimes play one on HN.

Regarding your noted normalcy bias, I would suggest you're forgetting the very many more points through recorded history with a centralized purveyor of force and taxation.

In that light, pointing out isolated counterexamples isn't very suggestive of some realistic future possibility for most or all of mankind, just as pointing out that Athens once had a direct democracy isn't very useful as a way to organize the governance of a nation.

Of course, the agorism you point out doesn't even have voting. I can only assume the idea is for some type of useful emergent behavior to come about, but that only talks about how the society would function internally, and it doesn't even really provide details about how that would work in all the important corner cases.

Is there some type of existing emergent societal system that you can point out which works in practice and need only be scaled up?

> As a nash equilibrium, an involuntary centralised productivity extracting parasitic force initiating agency is not at all stable. It stands to reason that it will only be able to maintain control by either force or fraud.

If by 'stable' you mean 'impossible to overturn' then I would argue that no political system meets this. If you mean 'can continue perpetually' then it is certainly a stable equilibrium, though it does unashamedly require force. Fraud alone can't keep it going in any event, otherwise police wouldn't be needed.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by etherael on Sunday September 08, 2013 @04:14AM (#6348157)
Are you really not a lawyer? As we've sparred fairly frequently over time I kinda wanted to get a feel for where you were coming from so I read through all your comment history for a while (though this was a while ago).

I just double checked that and saw this;

rayiner 671 days ago | link

As someone who left software engineering for law, I have to say that partnership is a great motivator.

and this;

rayiner 274 days ago | link | parent | flag

So I'm a lawyer and you should take my opinion with a grain of salt, but I think you've misread the market.

and this;

rayiner 303 days ago | link

So my grandfather on my mom's side was a doctor and a lawyer. My mom's siblings include a couple of doctors, a military officer, a business executive, etc. My mom was herself a journalist, and of her sons I'm a lawyer and my brother is a banker. This is not a coincidence. Privilege is passed down from generation to generation, not just in money, but in social status, connections, values, culture, insight, motivation, outlook, etc.

amongst a great many other descriptions of legal minutiae that I can see how I may have gotten that impression. But it leads me to wonder what your story actually is? Feel free to ignore this request if you think it's breaching privacy.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by etherael on Sunday September 08, 2013 @11:08PM (#6351618)
...

Aaaand I just realised I was talking to mpyne, not rayiner.

Sorry, you two share positions on so much I get you mixed up.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by etherael on Sunday September 08, 2013 @04:01AM (#6348139)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Machinery_of_Freedom

Describes a system based purely around free market mechanisms. Free markets are emergent, and they certainly work very well, scaling them up to consume all the functions currently performed by government in the methods described by this book is in my opinion the best method for abolishing the state I've heard of so far.

There are many other ideas however, and I'm open to any of them to the extent that they employ persuasion / markets rather than force.

> Fraud alone can't keep it going in any event, otherwise police wouldn't be needed.

Yes, when the lies stop being believable, then you need the jackboots to come in and crack skulls and assert the true facts of the way those in power see things. This is part of my problem with the system in question.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by CamperBob2 on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:27PM (#6343021)
If the police in my town were Federal agents, then yes, I would expect to have a somewhat different relationship with them. My town would feel "occupied," just as my computer now does.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:49PM (#6343280)
Well there are many towns where if the police were Federal agents, it would actually be an upgrade over the corruption and abuse the citizens normally see. So I don't understand any intuitive reason why the agency supplying the cops would necessarily make you feel differently, except perhaps for inherent biases.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by AnthonyMouse on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:08PM (#6343789)
>So I don't understand any intuitive reason why the agency supplying the cops would necessarily make you feel differently, except perhaps for inherent biases.

If you don't like what the cops in your town are doing then you can campaign for local political candidates who will rein them in and have some hope of actually affecting the election outcome. Getting anything similar done at the federal level seems to require some combination of mass fatalities that incense the public and a box truck filled with hundred dollar bills to grease the wheels, which is obviously outside the control and ability of most normal humans.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:21PM (#6343826)
> If you don't like what the cops in your town are doing then you can campaign for local political candidates who will rein them in and have some hope of actually affecting the election outcome.

That's a good point, but local civil servants enjoy due process too, so it's not always a matter of simply hiring the right politician, as the politician may not be able to simply fire or replace offending staff. Especially when we're talking about first responders, who typically enjoy strong union protection.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by CamperBob2 on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:46PM (#6343472)
If I don't like the local cops, I can move. Another libertarian principle that's worth defending.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by mpyne on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:49PM (#6343478)
Yes, the libertarian principle that it's OK to do whatever in a certain city as people who don't like it can always move away. Great principle. :P

Either way though, your logic applies just as much to Federal cops as it does to local ones. Think the FBI dudes around your city are a bunch of dicks? Move to the other coast, maybe they'll be better.

Hell, you can even pick an entirely different nations' cops, if you want.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by rayiner on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:07PM (#6342358)
We shouldn't, but that's besides the point, which is that the point in the article is wildly illogical.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by tptacek on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:40PM (#6342549)
I love Popehat, and Ken in particular, but any issue that intersects with his politics tends to get the same semilogical hyperbolic treatment. The "Buckyball" magnet thing was, if anything, even worse.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by thecoffman on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:28PM (#6343025)
I rather liked the Buckyball article personally, but I wanted to note that Ken, while probably the best author on Popehat, isn't the only one and the Buckyball article wasn't him; it was Clark. Clark's articles are often the explicitly libertarian ones.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by j2d3 on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:43PM (#6343263)
we do know that we are not allowed to know that