In particular, it turns out that "administration" doesn't scale linearly. A 4 person nonprofit still needs their ED to spend ~50% of time fundraising; there's likely >15% of your salary right there.
Information from folks that have done this for a while: http://philanthropy.com/article/3-Major-Charity-Groups-Ask/1...
Data, if you want: http://nonprofitquarterly.org/management/22239-new-study-low...
Even when it would be, "ratio of total spending to administration spending" probably is almost never the right single number.
Any nonprofit founder, should be able to answer a few questions; "How much do you, the founder expect in salary-- present and future. If we decide to fund your initial nonprofit, would you agree to work for these amounts?
If you want to make a large salary--start a for-profit business. There's nothing wrong with wanting to make a good living, but don't hide behind a nonprofit entity.
Oh yea, Obama is hip the nonprofit dance, but hasn't done anything. A few years ago, he wanted to separate legitimate nonprofits from just money making businesses. As far as I know, nothing has been done?
Certainly, having an objective measure of value produced and maximizing the ratio of that measure to total dollars spent is a good thing, but "dollars spent less admin costs" is not a good objective measure of value produced for most non-profits.
Guess what accounting bucket that goes into?
Sometimes (important word, sometimes) admin costs need to go above 10%. You have to spend money to make money.
If a business had an opportunity to spend 1 million dollars to make 2 million dollars, they would do it all day. (Taking into account their rate of return etc.) If a nonprofit had the opportunity to spend 1 million dollars to make 2 million, they might not, because they don't want their admin costs getting "too high".
1. At what percentage will your entity spend on administration costs?
2. Will you agree to keep it to less than 10%, if we give you funds?"
3. Flat out ask the future non-profit, "How much money do you feel you will need to run the non-profit. Would you agree to take only what the standard cost of living in the county you reside--if it succeeds?"
4. Will your BOD contain any family, friends, or relatives?
5.(Sorry if I sound callous; I live in a county where starting a non-profit is a career move. Some of the salaries are mind boggling.)
6. (Note to any future non-profit. I applaud your efforts if they are honest. Just a reminder--if you ever close down the 501(c)3 you can't keep any assets--not even a paper clip. Nothing belongs to you. )