Re:YC Will Now Fund Nonprofits Too
by notahacker on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:45PM
(#6343269)
With donor funded nonprofits the "product" is fulfilling the donors' wish to see money spent on X, so the litmus test for spending the money for donor-funded organizations should be if donors knew we were spending on this, would they change their mind about the donation. Rational, reasonable people won't mind some of their donation being spent soliciting further donations, but they will mind nearly all the money being spent on fundraising activity, to the point where it's essentially a marketing matrix giving little more than an "image rights" fee to the good causes.
Profit making companies like Tom's Shoes that see philanthropy as a core brand value, are a different matter. There's room for more of them irrespective of how the charitable sector organizes itself.
Re:YC Will Now Fund Nonprofits Too
by dragonwriter on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:52PM
(#6343294)
> With donor funded nonprofits the "product" is fulfilling the donors' wish to see money spent on X
I disagree. With donor funded nonprofits, the product can be to fulfill the donors wish to see their money achieving outcome X, not seeing their money spent on outcome X (it can also be as you present; different donors have different motives.)
I don't think that necessary challenges your conclusions, but I think it is an important distinction.
Re:YC Will Now Fund Nonprofits Too
by icebraining on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:40PM
(#6342547)
He was also in an hour-long episode of Econtalk: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2013/06/pallotta_on_cha.htm...
As a side note, I think that we've as a culture have been approaching non-profits entirely wrong [0]. Instead of letting them build structure to actually maximise the help they can give, we require them to be stripped-down organizations so their metrics can show they're giving as much money away as possible. This is why we've seen such a surge in for-profit-but-that's-not-the-main-point companies like Tom's Shoes lately. It's simply the best way to do the most good.
[0] http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pallotta_the_way_we_think_about...