Re:ESR: Computer Language Trends in 2009
by davidw on Saturday May 30, 2009 @05:40PM
(#634125)
As for why Tcl won't just up and die, see the SQLite testing thread. Tcl's built like that too, and built well: native threads, Unicode, a very extensive C API. Definitely some pieces missing (OO), but they are being actively worked on. In other words, Tcl is not the most popular thing out there by a long shot, but it's not "dying" either.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ESR: Computer Language Trends in 2009
by stcredzero on Saturday May 30, 2009 @11:45PM
(#634406)
Good, old languages are like good, old comic book characters. They might be declared dead, but someone's always going to bring them back.
Re:ESR: Computer Language Trends in 2009
by bayareaguy on Saturday May 30, 2009 @11:49PM
(#634409)
Tcl is still great when you need to whip up a testing wrapper for a C/C++ library but I think these days Lua is doing a better job at the original goal Tcl set out to accomplish.
I have to admit, I really like Tcl's syntax. Some issues, but it was something you could programmatically manipulate without huge pains. And the C interface was quite pleasant, particularly if you had ever dealt with contemporary Perl modules. I was looking into it many years ago as an extension language that was simultaneously not extraordinarily lame but not permitting you raw hardware access, either, and liked what I saw.
But the core design didn't age well, I don't think; dynamic variables, little consideration for modular programming, primitive data structuring tools, etc. I like looking at Tcl-without-the-warts type languages, but it's really just masturbation. Lua is almost as flexible and certainly better put together.
Yeah, I remember when I needed Tcl. I bought a book with good reviews, cleared a long Saturday afternoon and sat down to read. Shockingly few minutes later I'd learned the syntax and understood the idea... cool.
(I assume it is the same time frame as your experience, since yours were before the Inline::C module.)
Tcl may well get a second chance at glory with Parrot: http://code.google.com/p/partcl/
The whole interoperability with other languages on Parrot is going to be a game breaker IMHO.