News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by mseebach on Friday September 06, 2013 @10:42AM (#6340668)
The analogy is beyond flawed. Only houses that are indeed fortresses aren't routinely broken into if they are located anywhere near "a bad area". And even though the law is configured to punish those who break into houses, it rarely actually achieves it in practise.

Online, the fact that your presence must already be surrounded by a cryptographic fortress is well established, because the bad guys are lining up to wander straight in if you let down your guard. Law or no laws.

In your house, even if you have all the best protections, the government will enter your house if it feels it needs to. There are plenty of thoroughly unjust laws on the books (Civil forfeiture is particularly onerous: http://reason.com/archives/2010/01/26/the-forfeiture-racket).

The problem isn't the NSA, that's just another symptom in a long row where civil forfeiture is another. The root is that government has grown from being a servant of the people to considering itself the rightful ruler of the people (and plenty of people happily cheering along, even those who should know a lot better - see here for an example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6339434).

The author is correct that it shouldn't be necessary to protect ourselves against the government to this extend - but the important distinction in the surveillance case over the 'house' case is that we actually have a fighting chance, for once.

Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by rtpg on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:20AM (#6340853)
I find you choosing the roaming charge example to be bizarre: A lot of people here are pretty free-market, and the telecoms industry is not one of those free markets. It's dominated by few large corporations who piggy-backed off of large public investment (ultimately from the taxpayer).

This is one of the most legitimate uses of government : when the market fails, at least make sure that people are protected from being exploited.

Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by mseebach on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:42AM (#6340968)
It's relevant because you can't have your cake and eat it too. An organisation powerful enough to dictate prices for a service on the european market, is an organisation powerful enough to dictate, say, total data retention: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Retention_Directive
Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by rtpg on Friday September 06, 2013 @12:45PM (#6341315)
The price dictation is more of something similar to the WTO: roaming is pretty isomorphic to tariffs, in one sense. Technically speaking it isn't (tariffs do not represent anything other than some line, roaming is because you're actually on some other guy's network) but de facto larger carriers end up with plans to mutualise this anyways. Getting rid of tariffs is nice.

Also I don't see the link between price control and data retention. You're conflating everything under government. I'm pretty sure these two things underwent completely different processes.

Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by mseebach on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:16PM (#6341486)
You seem to be under the impression that there is a separate "evil" arm of governments that can be cut away somehow, letting you retain the good (or, rather, convenient) bits while getting rid of the bad ones.

That kind of fantasy is why we won't get rid of PRISM or the data logging directive. Government will only ever work for its own benefit, it's just that every once in a while, it's in its benefit to throw you a bone.

Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by rtpg on Saturday September 07, 2013 @06:15AM (#6344603)
actually yeah, what you're talking about is something called checks and balances, where the bad is mitigated as much as possible.

Even in your situation where government works in its own benefit, these are conflicting:

- The executive wants the data logging because it makes investigations easier , so less police work

- The judicial would not want this because it would make more open and shut cases, those reducing the need for workforce there

Even here , by applying your logic, checks and balances work

Re:Disagreeing with Bruce Schneier: More Crypto is Not the A... by mseebach on Saturday September 07, 2013 @07:39PM (#6347103)
That would be a wholly more convincing argument had checks and balances actually prevented the data retention directive and the NSA excesses. They didn't. Now what?