News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by kloncks on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:26PM (#6337807)
Square processes $10b. BrainTree processes $10b.

How is Square valued at $4b and BrainTree can't sell for $1b?

Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by abalone on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:39PM (#6338084)
Square probably has better gross margins than Braintree because they target a different market: small businesses.

The value Square adds to that market is much more substantial: free POS system, mobile wallet app, promotion in their marketplace, Jack Dorsey's autographed photo, etc.

Braintree (and Stripe) target ecommerce startups. Their value-add is streamlined APIs and tailored customer service. That value-add is nice but relatively smaller and less scalable to boot. As soon as those sites get big they will negotiate for lower rates they can get from a commodity processor. No doubt the big customers in their portfolio already have and we just don't know it.

Square's got a whole world of small business to expand into, a much larger market than ecommerce startups. And their margins are more sustainable; it takes an awful lot of growth for a merchant to justify switching out all their POS systems and other Square lock-in, just to shave a few basis points off their processing rate.

Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by tomkarlo on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:46PM (#6337894)
Valuation is based on growth and expected future profit more than current revenue or processing volume. If two companies both process $10bn, but one makes 3% and is growing 25% YoY while the other makes 1% and is growing 5%, they should have radically different valuations.
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by jordanthoms on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:32PM (#6337832)
Maybe it's because Square has a higher percentage of small merchants on their service, who can't negotiate better rates?
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by pedalpete on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:41PM (#6337873)
Isn't valuation is based on not only current revenue and business model but also forecasts and potential?

Square has a bit of a different opportunity than BrainTree as they are focusing on simplifying a real-world payments platform vs online and mobile payments. There seems to be less competition and a larger market for Square vs. Braintree I think.

Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by benologist on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:30PM (#6337823)
Growth, and probably Stripe plays no small part.
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by tlrobinson on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:32PM (#6337831)
That's not how valuations work. There are a lot more factors than current revenue. Their business models are somewhat different.
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by ajsharp on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:23PM (#6338031)
Growth potential, total potential market size, other possible revenue sources (e.g. Square Marketplace).
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by jfarmer on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:46PM (#6337893)
What are the first and second derivatives of those numbers with respect to time?
Re:Braintree Is On The Block, Had Acquisition Talks With Squ... by jacquesm on Friday September 06, 2013 @12:36AM (#6338688)
That's the right question to ask. The absolute values are important but not as important as the trends.