Re:The Whole Food Fallacy
by jonnathanson on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:12PM
(#6337045)
Agreed. Until I'm more confident that we've successfully learned all we need to learn, and reverse-engineered all we need to reverse-engineer -- and figured out which corners we can cut, and which we can't -- I'll take the whole foods wager when/if I can afford to.
All of that said, I am not a Vitalist. I am pretty sure biology is reducible, and that it can be reverse-engineered -- eventually. I just don't think we're sufficiently there yet.
In the meantime, I begrudge no one their choices, either way. And I applaud the Soylent team for its efforts. We should be doing more to reverse-engineer nature, so that we can get better at it. The best way to solve the problem is to keep trying and learning.
A main point of the article argued against there being a meaningful distinction between whole and "non-whole" foods,
but you've assumed there is. A main component of Soylent is rice protein -- do you think using just the rice protein is less "conservative" than putting whole rice in the mixture?
I applaud the Soylent creator for experimenting with his body and his life. I just hope that those who take this lifestyle leap, or any other, don't become too certain of their choice, because it turns out that biology is really, really hard.