Re:The Whole Food Fallacy
by ryanbrunner on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:04PM
(#6336971)
It confused me at first, the "isn't" is hard to catch. He's saying that there is not something irreducibly complex about food.
Re:The Whole Food Fallacy
by jonnathanson on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:08PM
(#6337006)
Yeah, it's not my finest sentence. I went back and italicized the "isn't," and maybe later I'll rethink the structure of that sentence entirely. It's a bit confusingly stated.
Re:The Whole Food Fallacy
by jonnathanson on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:02PM
(#6336956)
I think you misread my first sentence there. I said isn't, not is. :) As in: "the right argument isn't that there's something irreducibly complex. Instead, it's..."
I'm going to go back and italicize for emphasis.
Re:The Whole Food Fallacy
by steveklabnik on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:26PM
(#6337144)
Ah! Yes, something about it tripped me up. Thanks!
Re:The Whole Food Fallacy
by jonnathanson on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:11PM
(#6337738)
No worries. It's good feedback.
Sometimes I find myself writing quickly and sloppily on HN -- especially when I want to post comment before running off to a meeting (or what have you).
When stuff like this happens, though, it reminds me to tighten up my writing. Speed is no excuse for sloppiness!
> The more rational argument in favor of whole foods isn't that there's something fundamentally, irreducibly complex about them.
And
> It's a belief in some sort of "life force" that imbues the animal and vegetable kingdom, along with the implication that we'll never be able to recreate it.
? Is it that in the first, we have the possibility of knowing, but dont have the power yet? "Irreducably" suggests to me the same thing as "we'll never be able to recreate it."