News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Women Have Breasts by Tichy on Saturday May 30, 2009 @03:51AM (#633395)
"Look at women, and see if they have a pair of round wobbly things on their chests."

That kind of thing always made me wonder a bit: can genes really encode for "like round wobbly things on chests"? There would have to be a complete image recognizer implemented in the genes?

Not that I am saying it is impossible, but maybe it also works together with breast-feeding for a bit (as infants we get exposed to a lot of breast, so that would be an opportunity to learn to like them). And people do develop different and weird things to be attracted to.

Just saying maybe the genes don't encode "like breasts" directly, maybe they encode "like that stuff you are exposed to as a baby" (more specific than that, of course, not everything we are exposed to as infants becomes sexy).

Re:Why Women Have Breasts by joeyo on Saturday May 30, 2009 @11:56AM (#633779)

  > There would have to be a complete image recognizer
  > implemented in the genes?
Are you questioning the fact that humans and animals have image recognizers? Or do you doubt that genes play a major role in their development?
Re:Why Women Have Breasts by Tichy on Saturday May 30, 2009 @01:02PM (#633848)
No, of course humans have image recognizers. I just question that they come preprogrammed with a recognition loop for breasts. Obviously our image recognizers can learn after birth, that is, not all images we recognize are given to us by the genes.

It seems easier to me program reactions to smells, for example, as they are mostly binary receptors?

Also, coming back to the seagull example, I think there are no equivalents for faking beaks to faking breasts? A breast has to look fairly real to be attractive, it is not enough to just have a huge circle with another circle inside of it.

Re:Why Women Have Breasts by joeyo on Saturday May 30, 2009 @01:38PM (#633887)
I think it is at least plausible that some fairly complex image recognition could be genetically determined. Indeed, the classic example of the seagull proves that pre-programming such circuitry is possible in animals with significantly simpler brains than mammals. I don't think it's such a wild leap that more complicated image recognition could be possible at birth.

At any rate, it's not even necessary that such image recognition be completely formed at birth. It can develop along with the rest of the visual system and other systems that are tuned for sexual attractiveness. (I'm ignoring breasts-for-food-purposes, the recognition of which is largely determined by tactile stimuli, mediated by the trigeminal nerve).

Re:Why Women Have Breasts by jibiki on Saturday May 30, 2009 @12:29PM (#633813)
I think that this is relevant.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=410778

The article explains the level of image recognition that is available to seagulls from birth (i.e., genetically.) Basically, you can trick them into thinking beak-like objects are actually their mother's beak.

As for the question at hand, we have to ask what happens to a male who never sees any breasts before adulthood. Will he still find them attractive?

Re:Why Women Have Breasts by Tichy on Saturday May 30, 2009 @12:58PM (#633843)
I seem to remember from school that the beak recognition is not very good, either. Just any big yellow thing would do - don't know about the seagull specifically, though. Also, they don't recognize if the beak is attached to a seagull or something else.
Re:Why Women Have Breasts by cturner on Saturday May 30, 2009 @07:29AM (#633525)

    There would have to be a complete image recognizer
    implemented in the genes?
We have such patterns for detecting spiders and snakes from slight movements, so much so that you will sometimes pick it up when a leaf blows just so.
Re:Why Women Have Breasts by Tichy on Saturday May 30, 2009 @09:12AM (#633599)
That does not seem to be a very complex pattern recognizer then. It does not recognize spiders, just small, fast movements. I seem to remember from school that it is quite easy to recognize such things with simple neural networks (even frog brains can do it).

I would think recognizing a breast would be more complex (since simply circles with dots in them are not as attractive, or are they?).