Amen. Schools are failing SOME kids, there is no doubt about that.
But the question I have - which is controversial, to say the least - is this: Do we really CARE that it's failing some kids?
Do we have to make everybody go all the way through THE PROCESS, or should some rightly just skip a chunk of it?
EDIT: My first comment to you is mostly in agreeance with you. I think it's inarguable that school fails SOME kids, because no compulsory system is perfect. But I took your statement of "are schools really failing kids" to mean "are schools really failing the majority or even all kids" or something similar (are schools failing the most important kids for some value of "important", etc).
That doesn't seem to make it more clear, but hell, I'm trying to vigorously agree with you.
I think what people really want is the economy to be better, and since the economy isn't what it used to be, the popular theory is that at some point, the education system got infected with some disease and started to fail kids, causing the bad economy. When the economy was humming, I doubt many people thought the education system failed those kids. The simpler explanation is that the education system was in a relatively steady state and the economy just went bad.
A lot of people are in agreement that the problem begins and ends with teachers, but this sounds suspiciously like scapegoating.