News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:School is a prison and damaging our kids by VLM on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @05:28PM (#6330629)
I have two teachers in the family. The primary observation is their management is intensely toxic. So "changing the rules" is primarily oriented around, well, basically screwing over management's enemies using some new rules. It has nothing to do with punishing the "bad" teachers and everything to do with punishing the ones who don't kiss up or are in certain protected or unprotected demographic groups.

Student outcomes is ridiculous because given a reasonably small class size all you're doing is grading the randomness of the kid distribution aka you'll be rewarding / punishing teachers based on which specific kids they get that year. Sometimes a good year, sometimes bad. Statistically its far more valid to grade folks at a higher level aka a larger sample size, so obviously this should be implemented to grade district leaders and principals first... LOL that will never happen because it'll only exist as a weapon.

Making it an even worse weapon, most of the people doing the coaching are the ones in charge of assigning kids to teachers. So you can't fire a teacher for being a black woman, even if you hate black women. But if coincidentally you hate black women and are in charge of assigning kids and the 24 year old single hottie white woman just happens to "randomly" get all the angelic gifted and talented wonderkids, and the uppity black woman happens to have assigned to her all the village morons and wannabe gang members, well I guess the black woman's numbers are going to suck. And thats how, if you hate black women, you legally fire black woman teachers. There's a thin veneer of BS about accountability as a marketing technique to deploy the weapon, but its all about another weapon for toxic management.

Your reading example is ridiculous as I recently completed the same age range with my kids. The argument is that English as a language is completely screwed up with innumerable exceptions. So when the teacher is trying to teach basic phonic sound #17 or whatever, its not helping matters if you confuse the kid with peculiar exception 34 B subsection W item 6.

I understand there are perfectly phonetic languages where what you see is what you get. And there are languages situations where you just have to memorize Kanji. But at least in theory you can teach English to most kids successfully by gradually piling on first basic rules and later weird rules and finally shoveling exceptions on.

Frankly I learned how to read English from pure raw memorization and lots of reading. That's not how kids are taught today. There seems to be little point in blaming teachers or unions for the decision of middle managers in the admin building who selected a particular curriculum. You can homeschool kids using this curriculum you're making fun of if you want, it's a policy decision that has nothing to do with licensing the front line workers or their union or frankly even their immediate supervisors...

Re:School is a prison and damaging our kids by aestra on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:52AM (#6334145)
>I learned how to read English from pure raw memorization and lots of reading. That's not how kids are taught today

How are kids taught today? I don't remember how I learned English (it is my native language) but I think I know how I mastered it, lots of practice. Writing, reading, reading, and more reading.