News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000) by MartinCron on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @01:21PM (#6328991)
If I came into work today and brought up the idea of doing a complete code rewrite, I'd either get laughed out of the room, or even worse, threatened with being fired

If that's really the case, then you're working with a bunch of abusive, pedantic, and narrow-sighted assholes. I will generally say "no" to the idea of a complete code rewrite of any meaningful and currently useful system (based on my own experience as much as Joel's article), but I won't laugh at people or threaten to fire them over it.

Re:Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000) by umsm on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @03:18PM (#6329773)
Or they may have experience with people that walk in and declare all code as "insecure" and "dangerous" or "unusable". They usually promise the world and deliver a small fraction, if even that.

Then, for the next 9 months delay the "1 month" project week after week. The product owners love this one. It cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars to get to square one again.

And all of this happening to a product that wasn't released yet.

At the end, the developer quit and everyone in the company agreed that it was good to see them leave.

Re:Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000) by MartinCron on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @03:35PM (#6329894)
Good to see you're not bitter about that.
Re:Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000) by umsm on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @04:01PM (#6330068)
Well, I am young, so I may go through something like this again. But at the moment, I was totally against it.

Now, when something like this comes up again, I learned enough to PLAN through it better. Realistic deadlines will make any work place a better place to be.

Re:Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000) by MartinCron on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @04:12PM (#6330138)
Of course, and it is easier to plan for incremental replacement and refactoring than for a wholesale re-write.