I think the parent is correct in that Google is now moving the value added components of their Operating System (as opposed to the more "core" elements of the OS, into closed source and fully under Google's control. It's a rational move, and I applaud them for their cleverness.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darwin_%28operating_system%29
"Darwin is now only available as source code,[5] except for the ARM variant, which has not been released in any form separately from iOS."
Symbian? OpenMoko? The upcoming SailfishOS, Tizen, Firefox OS, and Ubuntu phone? Oh, you meant in the U.S., I guess. (Yes, I know that all the above have either already largely failed or have sketchy futures. That's an entirely different kettle of fish.)
> Open source fanatics are impossible to satisfy
All I want is the ability to make arbitrary changes to the software running on my phone. Why is that so hard?
What mainstream OS makes this easier than Android?
Considering the closed source bits of Android have no equivalent in Firefox OS I would say it's equally open source as Firefox OS.
Btw, the Linux kernel is the only GPL piece of code in Android. However closed Android is or will become, the kernel will still be provided because of the virulent license. Arguing Android is open because they ship the kernel that allows FirefoxOS and Ubuntu to boot on some devices is wrong because they are legally bound to ship this kernel, it's not an act of good will (but doesn't mean they wouldn't do it out of good will).
http://opensource.apple.com/release/mac-os-x-1084/
http://opensource.apple.com/release/ios-61/ (and a lot is shared with OS X, such as the xnu kernel)
If it matters: to be fair, Android was around before Google's involvement and they purchased the source + hired the developer (1), and the Linux core of Android also wasn't developed by Google, IIRC.
(1) they probably did more work on Android than Apple did on CUPS, but that's a gradual difference.
And you try and tell the young people of today that ..... they won't believe you.
And most technologically astute people (young or old) know that OSX relies extensively on UNIX software of which CUPS is just one part.
"It was bad because it was a new operating system." -- it was already bad in the pre-OSX Mac era (mostly due to low marketshare).
"And it wasn't just printers but everything. Drivers, applications, utilities. They all took years to move to OSX." -- for applications and most other things Apple had migration alternatives (Carbon APIs for pre-OSX Mac apps, the Classic environment for emulation of pre-OSX and even Rosetta for emulating PowerPC on Intel).
For the case of printers, they really just dropped whatever they had and went with the Linux solution.
Open source fanatics are impossible to satisfy, they will always find a reason why the flavor of open source that a company or an organization picked is not the "real" open source, but the simple truth is that I can load up the source of Android in any IDE and start debugging into Android's system libraries any time I need it.
Good luck getting this from Apple.