1) You're right: It's bad, but in order to open connections to different clients it needs a signed applet. I also considered a custom plugin but I thought forcing a user to install it could be ever worse. Do you have any better idea?
2) True, will remove it.
I think reducing publisher's costs could lead to benefits even for consumers, I'm thinking about hd videos.
If you employed this technology & it took off I suspect you would be faced with very angry ISP's who may well ban access from their networks.
Plus of course it eats right into the users BW - they theoretically will upload more than they download and with limited BW allowances people could easily start gettign traffic shaped without even knowing why!
That said it's a neat solution to the BW problem.. something of a catch 22.
And while I don't think ISPs really care about you maxing out a phone line, they will notice you maxing out a broadband line. And bittorent will do that.
Ask any ISP :) P2P sucks for them.
1) Being forced to click "Trust" just to watch a video is pretty bad, and would turn away many of your users.
2) Having an alert box "Are you sure you want to leave this page?" is also pretty bad, and unnecessary.
Overall, I can see the value that this technology gives to you (less bandwidth). But what value do you give to the consumer? Why would I want to endure the various hassles of this site, and give up some my scarce upstream bandwidth, when I could just go to Youtube or Vimeo instead?