News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:01AM (#6315169)
At the risk of being "not HN".

no duh

These revelations, that "The NSA spied on <insert>" are unimportant beyond "The NSA spied on Americans". Every country spies on every other country. Welcome to being a grown up. I'd be sad if the NSA wasn't spying on the Brazilian and Mexican presidents.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by diego_moita on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:55AM (#6315416)
I don't think you get it. Btw, I am Brazilian.

First let's state the obvious: Brazilians spy on Brazilians. Clandestine telephone wiretaps are a regular thing in this country; the Brazilian secrete service (ABIN) and even private detectives do it a lot.

But, still, there are 3 implications in this story:

1) Every company in this country with secrets to hide (a.k.a every company) will now develop an allergic reaction to the words "cloud computing".

2) Every Brazilian IT company that has potential American competition now has the perfect argument for protectionism.

3) Expect a lot more laws regarding "internet regulation". Politicians here are eager for any excuse for doing it.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @12:30PM (#6315853)
Are you saying that the fact the NSA spies on every country on the planet hitting CBS news changes anything?

The NSA isn't exactly the March of Dimes. It's a spy agency tasked with spying. Everybody knows the NSA spies on everybody, anybody who doesn't or expects otherwise is hopelessly naive.

Is it nice? No, not really. And in a better world the NSA wouldn't exist. But it's not a better world and thus the NSA exists. This stuff will continue to make the news for a while, people will feign shock at their own ignorance then it will fade away.

I see lots of comments here about how the NSA's recruitment image is now tarnished, is it? Does anybody ever try and get work at the NSA with the expectation that they won't be part of a giant spy apparatus? What exactly do people think crypto experts do?

Sure Brazilians might have some short term reaction, but long term it won't amount to a hill of beans.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by coldtea on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:02PM (#6315988)
>Are you saying that the fact the NSA spies on every country on the planet hitting CBS news changes anything?

Of course it does. Public disclosure changes things. Even things that everybody "just knew" went on, act differently on public discussion when they take front scene.

>Everybody knows the NSA spies on everybody, anybody who doesn't or expects otherwise is hopelessly naive.

Well, tell it to the "hopelessly naive" people on HN that for years maintained otherwise.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:46PM (#6316208)
> Public disclosure changes things.

We'll see. I hope you're right, but what exactly should it change? The NSA is a spy agency after all. There's lots of people here who think that the NSA should knock nicely and ask politely if they can bug your phone...and that you should be able to get a complete log of what they listen to as if the NSA was just some kind of national phone conversation backup service bureau.

I see lots of sabre rattling in Congress, people on the Intelligence Committee who are shocked shocked that their "oversight" has been revealed to be insufficient and other members of Congress who are equally shocked that you need gasp a security clearance to see classified stuff. But I don't really see anything particularly material happening.

The material things that are happening is that the NSA is making it even harder for a future Snowden-alike to do the same.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by teamgb on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:19PM (#6316063)
Just because something is supposedly legal in one country, doesn't make it legal in the rest of the world.

What if the Saudi Religious Police mounted operations around the world - beating women for wearing mini-skirts or chopping heads off men for being gay?

Would you be okay with that because it's legal in Saudi Arabia? Would you just shrug your shoulders and move on?

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:37PM (#6316156)
What are you saying, that spying should only be done with the legal consent of the other government?

I don't think you understand what "spying" means.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by powertower on Monday September 02, 2013 @11:55AM (#6315694)
We get it.

Edward Snowden is attempting to hurt American interests, rather than expose some horrible crime against the US people. While the self-promoting hacks he picked as journalists continue to do what they do best, fabricate stories that don't really exists once you put the facts on the table and use the proper context.

That's the only way I can understand what he is doing right now, unless he really thinks the truth must come out purely for the sake of the truth, and secrets cannot exist. In which case he is extremely immature and doesn't understand the way the world operates.

In the mean time, he will continue to cause problems for the US. While the rest of the world uses these leaks for their own benefits. It will keep him relevant.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by rdl on Monday September 02, 2013 @11:24AM (#6315561)
I'd be angry if NSA didn't spy on foreign militaries. Foreign heads of state, to the extent that they control their militaries, are members of militaries.

Spying on US persons (except intelligence community people, for counterintelligence purposes) should be out. Counterterrorism involving US persons should be law enforcement. I might change my mind if real domestic-origin NBC threats were a thing, but as far as I can tell, they are not.

Spying on foreign civilian arms vendors, maybe some key infrastructure, etc. is ok if it is done in a very limited way -- pure open source intelligence (monitoring public information, usually published by the target, and voluntary reports from people) is probably reasonable.

Spying on purely-private, non-threatening non-US-persons is bad for two reasons. At some level, it's immoral directly -- there is a human right to privacy at some level. As well, it's a total waste of resources -- if NSA has the resources to spy on a private Brazilian citizen who is cheating on his wife, the NSA has too many resources, either more properly used for other governmental purposes or returned to the taxpayers.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by cyphax on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:15AM (#6315238)
What? It'd be sad if the US DIDN'T spy on other, friendly nations? And, am I not a grown up for seriously being angry about all this then?
Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by shin_lao on Monday September 02, 2013 @11:26AM (#6315574)
Being angry is a normal reaction, but that doesn't mean spying on "friends" isn't the thing to do.

It's not black and white. You don't just have "friends" on one side and "enemies" on the others.

It can also be understood as "Trust but verify" - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=As6y5eI01XE

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by Xylakant on Monday September 02, 2013 @12:09PM (#6315748)
So you'd be fine if your partner breaks into your email account on the basis of "trust but verify"? [1] I'm not. The NSA/GCHQ are breaking into secured computer systems of other countries and the UN despite having signed treaties that forbid this practice. They use the information gained to undermine the negotiation position of their partners. Now, that this information gets published, it's "what everybody does", but back when american systems were hacked, it was "evil chinese hackers".

I'm not willing to accept that "what everybody does" is always a good practice. The USA is currently loosing a lot of goodwill and trust with other countries due to the NSAs actions. Those actions might have provided a short-term benefit in some negotiation, but now that they're exposed do a tremendous damage. I might be a bit of a dreamer, but I always hoped that governments should be in for the long-term benefit and fostering reciprocal trust between allies is certainly better than spying on them.

[1] trust but verify can be baked into treaties, as was done in the START treaties for example.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by shin_lao on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:03PM (#6315991)
If you wrongly entrust your partner, you might be cheated.

If you wrongly entrust another country, millions of persons might die.

Different consequences, different rules.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by Xylakant on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:30PM (#6316117)
If you wrongly spy on your partner, you might loose him.

If you wrongly spy on an ally, millions of persons might die.

Different consequences, different rules.

Your argument is a straw man. I never called for blind trust into all actions, but for trust in the countries you call your allies. Brasil is unlikely to start the next major war, as is Germany, France or the UN. Spying on those is all about leverage and financial benefits. Is that worth the loss of trust you're risking?

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by timdiggerm on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:42AM (#6315362)
Yes. That is their job. Because nations don't trust each other. Because, historically, they shouldn't. It would be naive to do otherwise.
Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:10PM (#6316024)
Who said Mexico and Brazil are friends of the US? Mexico and Brazil both represent significant economic threats to the U.S. And Brazil's fast growing economy and military power, with a population 2/3s that of the U.S. and unbelievably vast untapped natural resources will likely continue to skew the center of power in the Americas south. Brazil is now a larger economic power than the UK and a hair behind France if that puts things into perspective. Brazil has the largest and most powerful military force in Latin America that includes limited deep water force projection capabilities.

Mexico is a larger economy than South Korea. It's a "partner" in the war on drugs and is the major conduit for illicit drugs entering the US. It's military is supplied by countries that aren't necessarily "friends" of the US, it has a reputation for rampant corruption and out of control criminal enterprises. And oh yeah it shares one of the longer land borders with the U.S. and unbelievable number of Mexican citizens skirt border checkpoints in one of the largest human migrations in history that will inevitably result in massive cultural, economic and political changes in the U.S.

I'm not upset about these things, it's just the nature of changing times. But thinking that the U.S. and Brazil and Mexico and special BFFs and wouldn't ever, under any circumstances even do super secret double probation spying of any sort on each other has no other word than naive to describe it.

> And, am I not a grown up for seriously being angry about all this then?

Yeah, that's pretty much what I'm saying. Welcome to the very scary, duplicitous, wretched grown up world where friendship is only out of beneficial convenience and allies work to subvert each other while still trying to achieve mutual goals.

When you start getting sad about this, instead of angry, then you've grown up.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by dictum on Monday September 02, 2013 @02:11PM (#6316334)
> Who said Mexico and Brazil are friends of the US? Mexico and Brazil both represent significant economic threats to the U.S.

I'm sure the US won't get any goodwill from other nations as long as it keeps seeing any other economic power not in decline as an enemy.

Why the condescension for people who don't accept realpolitik as a fact of life?

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @03:13PM (#6316616)
I think lots of the anger here is not about realpolitik vs ideology as much as pure willful ignorance, wishful thinking and possibly outright delusion.

There's lots of tut-tutting here about the NSA doing what the NSA is supposed to do under the guise of mock upsetness or outright ignorance. But here, when Germany is demonstrated to be part of it? Barely a righteous tone rises in anger.

China outright infiltrates a nuclear weapons lab? Well shame on the US for not vetting their people better. [1] Lets not ever chastise China.

Russia has spies embedded in the US banking industry for a decade? Oh that silly Putin! Here's a picture of him wrestling a bear!

But the NSA breaking codes and tapping phones? Oh my goodness fuck! What will save us from the Stalinist purges!

What precisely do we think the DGSE, MI5, MI6, BND, MAD, CNI, SVR, NSB etc. [3] all do? Rescue local cats from trees? Play with computers and microphones to see "what's cool?"

There's lots of smart folks here, but it's like we're all drunk at our keyboards every time the NSA is shown to be doing what the NSA is supposed to be doing.

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_intelligence_activity_...

2 - http://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/jul/22/germany-china-i...

3 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_intelligence_agencies

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by coldtea on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:00PM (#6315980)
>Every country spies on every other country.

No, they do not. Most countries wouldn't even dream of spying on other countries (with the exception of their direct enemies in their periphery), and even if they did, they wouldn't know what to do with the information.

A lot of small countries not only do not spy, but they voluntary let other large countries spy on them and handle over their citizens data.

The countries that do spy "on every other country" are large countries, those with foreign interests that they take care of. The kind of countries that push their business/trade/diplomatic etc agenda to the world. Somebody really believes that, say, Belize spies on Germany? Or Nigeria spies on the UK?

Second, while they do do it, even large countries are not supposed to spy on their so-called allies, and not at the level of the wiretaping their head of state.

>Welcome to being a grown up.

That's not "being a grown up". That's being infantilized, accepting the status quo because "that's how it goes".

One could imagine people saying the same thing to blacks fighting for civil rights: "Well, of course you don't count as much as whites in this country, duh, welcome to the grown up world".

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:36PM (#6316147)
> No, they do not.

Yes they do.

Do you think that everybody in say, a diplomatic mission from Nigeria on tour of a UK tank factory isn't looking for a leg up? Spying comes in all forms -- it's not just 007 movie stuff.

A harmless looking tour will get turned into detailed reports that will be cross referenced with other reports to build a picture of British industrial capacity or products. So the next time Nigeria has a water dispute with Chad they can assess the quality of the armored Land Rovers Chad just purchased.

For goodness sakes, Nigeria has to manage territory larger than Pakistan and you think they don't have an intelligence apparatus?

Here's their homepage! https://www.nationalintelligenceagency.gov.ng/ (it's down for now, but 1 guess as to what their mission is)

You want to talk small? I've personally met members of Trinidad and Tobago's National Intelligence Ministry and had a lovely talk about their work in Europe. National interests come in all shapes and sizes. It's not just about who you might go to war against, but about who might be sending huge groups of unruly tourists to your resorts so you have to invest in extra police forces.

>A lot of small countries not only do not spy, but they voluntary let other large countries spy on them and handle over their citizens data.

Sheesh. Talk about infantilizing! That's not even respectful of other country's ability to look out for themselves.

A list

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_intelligence_agencies

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by coldtea on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:35PM (#6317322)
>Do you think that everybody in say, a diplomatic mission from Nigeria on tour of a UK tank factory isn't looking for a leg up?

A leg up on what? Are they going to steal the tank designs and create their own in the (virtually non existing) nigerian arms industry?

Small countries have neither the means to spy on bigger countries, nor what to do with that information. Most often than not, lots of their diplomatic and political personel is already on the payroll of some larger power (banana republic style). Not to mention the horrible repurcusions they would face if they were caught spying on a larger country.

Some small stuff happens from time to time, but in 99% of case a country like Nigeria spies on neighborhooding countries, with which they have direct feuds (old war enemies, land disputes, etc).

>Spying comes in all forms -- it's not just 007 movie stuff.

Never said it was 007 movie stuff. We were actually discussing spying in the form of surveillance, which is totally non 007 anyway.

What I said is it's that spying makes no sense for countries that cannot do anything with the information.

>For goodness sakes, Nigeria has to manage territory larger than Pakistan and you think they don't have an intelligence apparatus?

No, I very much think they have an intelligence apparatus. For spying on their own citizens and neighborhind countries. What I said was false is that "every country spies on all other countries", and especially that small countries (influence and might-wise, not land-wise) spy on larger powers.

>Sheesh. Talk about infantilizing! That's not even respectful of other country's ability to look out for themselves.

Those countries (over 70% of them) have been colonies for centuries (and now post-colonies). What "ability to look out for themselves"?

The very notion of a country like Trinidad and Tobago spying on any large power is laughable, whatever tall tales members of it's intelligence ministry say.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @08:31PM (#6318024)
> A leg up on what? Are they going to steal the tank designs and create their own in the (virtually non existing) nigerian arms industry?

The fact that you have to ask that means you fundamentally don't understand what spying is for.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by powertower on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:26PM (#6316095)
> Most countries wouldn't even dream of spying on other countries

Contradictory to all known history. They all dream of it. Some of those are even full out wet dreams.

> Somebody really believes that, say, Belize spies on Germany? Or Nigeria spies on the UK?

Infantile, small, and poor countries don't have the knowhow and resources to effectively spy on other more-advanced nations.

That's the only reason they "don't",... because they "can't".

It's not a moral stand.

> A lot of small countries not only do not spy, but they voluntary let other large countries spy on them and handle over their citizens data.

Don't worry, they either get paid, or get some benefit from that arrangement.

> One could imagine people saying the same thing to blacks fighting for civil rights: "Well, of course you don't count as much as whites in this country, duh, welcome to the grown up world".

Nice analogy, that's broken in every way.

I'm also not going to fall for the trap of paralleling this to a race issue.

Nations fight for self-interests first and foremost, not for the interests of other nations, big or small.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by coldtea on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:43PM (#6317353)
>Contradictory to all known history. They all dream of it. Some of those are even full out wet dreams.

No, they really are not. In fact in the last 2-3 centuries of known history, most countries, not only wouldn't spy on large powers, but were under their direct command, as colonies.

>Infantile, small, and poor countries don't have the knowhow and resources to effectively spy on other more-advanced nations. That's the only reason they "don't",... because they "can't". It's not a moral stand.

Well, that's what I said too. Although I disagree on the latter part: not spying, even if is because you can't, gives you a moral high ground.

>>A lot of small countries not only do not spy, but they voluntary let other large countries spy on them and handle over their citizens data.

>Don't worry, they either get paid, or get some benefit from that arrangement.

The lackeys in government yes. The countries (as in, the general public, no). They are royally fucked over from that arrangements (see: banana republic).

>Nations fight for self-interests first and foremost, not for the interests of other nations, big or small.

There are ways to go about your self-interests as a nation that makes you a jack-ass and there are ways that are better. Nazi germany went after their self-interests too.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by selectodude on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:57AM (#6315426)
I think what people are most aghast about is finding out exactly how good the NSA/CIA are at spying. I'm personally not surprised by any of it, but I think it's news to a lot of people.
Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by thezach on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:18AM (#6315253)
And I'm sure Mexico and Brazil did their best to spy on the US... its the nature of things. Countries spy on other countries.
Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by Zigurd on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:59AM (#6315441)
> "And I'm sure Mexico and Brazil did their best to spy on the US"

That might be true. But the US is an outlier. The US spends more on the military than the rest of the world combined, and that ratio probably extends to the intelligence budget.

So while the Mexicans might "do their best" to spy on America, that might be pretty far down their overall budget priorities.

Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by illumen on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:23AM (#6315274)
spying is jerk behaviour
Re:Report: NSA spied on Brazilian, Mexican presidents by bane on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:41PM (#6316184)
No argument from me there.

Spying is not something "nice" people do in the general sense.