Re:The Worst Programming Environment in the World?
by logicallee on Monday September 02, 2013 @09:51AM
(#6315127)
I've thought about your statements and probably you do have enough evidence to back it up. This is an unusual case, and the evidence should be reported more fully when it is stated. i.e. people shouldn't just claim this without reciting the facts in detail.
More generally, I would not try to read that much about people's personality from their writings on the Internet.
I suppose in an exceptional case like this you can. But isn't it enough to say that the guy cannot communicate without derailing himself onto delusional-sounding and off-topic religious interjections?
That would not require a diagnosis and would explain to everyone why the community regards him the way it does.
The idea that supposed prophets were often schizophrenic is hardly a novel notion to academia.
I'm unclear on your motive here. Do you want everyone to think he and anyone else acting similarly is a troll simply to be dismissed? Are you arguing for simply demonizing the mentally ill rather than offering any understanding, because there's a chance they might be trolls? And if they are trolls, might that not be a symptom of a different sort of mental illness?
I assume you're trying to accomplish some sort of goal you think worthwhile, but I'm at a loss to understand what it might actually be.