News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by jamesaguilar on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:07PM (#6312359)
Yep. If your job could conceivably be done by an automaton, eventually it will be. Since we are just automatons, that means that every job could eventually be automated. Which is ok. I'd rather not have to work. But it's also basically proof that someday we'll need socialism because there will be no jobs at all.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by _ak on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:30PM (#6312648)
Socialism is such a harsh word.

All it really needs is a welfare program for the general population that doesn't punish those whose jobs have been automated.

A system how to solve that has been discussed in Germany by left-leaning parties. The idea is simple: give everyone a certain salary per month that allows them to rent a flat, buy groceries, and have a social life. Without the fear of losing their job, not being able to afford food or just becoming poor, people will do whatever they like: some will continue their job (which earns them extra pay, obviously), some will try out a business idea they have, some won't work. Or that's the idea, at least, with the assumption that people aren't lazy by nature and thus must be punished if they neither work nor actively seek for jobs (i.e. the current unemployment benefit system in Germany), but instead would like to work, except working on the stuff they like working on.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by azernik on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:32PM (#6312840)
I don't know why you think socialism is a "harsh" word - those same leftist parties in Germany and the rest of Europe call themselves Socialist or Social Democratic and are proud of it.

It's only on the US where Socialism is such a term of abuse on even the left of the political spectrum.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by bradleyjg on Sunday September 01, 2013 @10:49PM (#6313226)
Left wing politicians call themselves socialist in Europe because it has positive connotations in certain circles over there. In the US right wing politicians call somewhat less right wing politicians socialist because it has a negative connotation to many Americans.

They are both wrong. Socialism involves collective ownership of the means of production, not capitalism plus a welfare state.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by btilly on Sunday September 01, 2013 @09:36PM (#6313018)
Not all of the left though.

There is actually an open socialist in the US Senate. Senator Bernie Sanders from Vermont. He's surprisingly widely liked.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by gaius on Monday September 02, 2013 @03:44AM (#6313948)
he idea is simple: give everyone a certain salary per month that allows them to rent a flat, buy groceries, and have a social life

The cost of the welfare system in the UK is such that it would actually be cheaper to just give every man, woman and child in the UK 3000/year no questions asked, no strings attached. Could a single person live on 3000/year in London? Well it was a long time ago now, but I did, as did millions of others, when we were students. Could a family of 4 live on 12000 somewhere like Wales, today? Sure, especially if it was supplemented by a little casual work from one or both parents. And we'd need to stabilize the population too.

People say I'm a fascist because I want to abolish the welfare state, but it's not true: I merely wish to abolish the department that runs it and go direct!

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by rmc on Monday September 02, 2013 @06:59AM (#6314534)
Could a single person live on 3000/year in London? Well it was a long time ago now, but I did, as did millions of others, when we were students.

Are you adjusting for inflation? Did you get £3,000 a long time ago? Or did you get what is now worth £3,000? 3k in 2000 is the same as 4.2k, in '95 it's the same as 4.8k now, in '90 it's like 5.7k now.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by gaius on Tuesday September 03, 2013 @05:17AM (#6319892)
It's a long time ago now, but IIRC the grant was something like £2200/year. I worked about 10 hours a week at £3/hr on top of that.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by rmc on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @04:58AM (#6326379)
How long ago? We can calculate how much it's worth in today's money.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by gaius on Wednesday September 04, 2013 @09:50AM (#6327511)
Call it 20 years.

I'm not saying it would be a necessarily desirable lifestyle mind, but if you're young and all your friends are in the same boat, that much plus a little part-time work was enough to live on, certainly.

The point it, tho', we in the UK could afford that level of minimum income guarantee, as in that's what the welfare state costs right now. If we need more then we'd need to decide where that money was going to come from.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by prostoalex on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:41PM (#6312685)
This already kinda exists in the United States, except not in the salary form. Food stamps + subsidized housing + disability pay.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by igravious on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:18PM (#6312804)
Honest question. What kind of life does that give you? A decent enough life or a pretty miserable life?

Also, if this is true why are there so many more homeless people in the US than any other Western country I've been to?

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by jamesaguilar on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:51PM (#6312900)
It doesn't give you a very good life. That said, there is still a question of when we should begin heavily subsidizing non-work. I think there's a decent argument to be made that we're not at that point yet.

Also, homelessness in the US is barely related to the question of subsidizing non-work. It's more of a failure on the part of our mental health system. If you talk to a homeless guy in the US, odds are he'll have some pretty noticeable mental issue right from the get-go.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by bradleyjg on Sunday September 01, 2013 @11:10PM (#6313281)
SSI (disabled from birth) is $600 a month. SSDI (disabled after working for some time, generally 10 years) is $900-$3000 a month. Food stamps top out at $200 for an individual and a little more than $600 for a family of four. Section 8 (housing subsidies) is based on a complicated formula but in NYC can amount to a $1800 subsidy for a family of four.

People on SSI + Food Stamps + Section 8 + Medicaid certainly aren't living the lifestyles of the rich and famous, but their effective income at PPP is comparable the median household income in a country like Czech Republic or Portugal.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by dwiel on Sunday September 01, 2013 @11:39PM (#6313359)
At least in Indiana where I love, these aren't guaranteed. Food stamps only last for a year or two and then you're done, even if you are still in a bad situation. Subsidized housing is a lottery with something like 1:4 odds. Even if you are lucky enough to get these things, you aren't in a stable position, because they can be taken away from you.

I also think the comments here about how its luxury compared to a 3rd world are true, but also note that it is more expensive to live here, and there are very few fallback options if the government programs don't work out. The homeless in my town don't have a shelter they can legally sleep at, and with all of the regulations we have in place, a minimally legal structure still has a pretty high cost.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by prostoalex on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:26AM (#6313568)
We're discussing basic income, so the point is more the survival and freeing up time to do anything one ever wanted outside of work.

Depression is a valid point though, something that's frequently omitted in such discussions, which center on the fact that if only you provided people with ATM cards, things would be nice and clean and drug-free.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by Daniel_Newby on Sunday September 01, 2013 @09:53PM (#6313062)
It gives you a life of luxury barely imaginable to the average person in Bangladesh.

The US is strongly anti-authoritarian. Rounding up the crazies and putting them in a managed home simply is not done. It would infringe the civil rights of burned out alcoholics, schizophrenics, etc.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by _ak on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:48AM (#6314339)
That's not it at all. Food stamps and subsidized housing don't empower people to just do what they like doing, become entrepeneurs, etc.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by seiji on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:37PM (#6312465)
From 1994 (I welcome any earlier references too):

An easy change in the United States could be through the social security system. Social security was originally presented as a government-run pension fund that accumulated wages for retirement, but in practice it transfers income from workers to retirees. The system will probably be subsidized from general taxes in coming decades, when too few workers are available to support the retiring post World War II baby boom. Incremental expansion of such a subsidy would let money from robot industries, collected as corporate taxes, be returned to the general population as pension payments. By gradually lowering the retirement age towards birth, most of the population would eventually be supported. The money could be distributed under other names, but calling it a pension is meaningful symbolism: we are describing the long, comfortable retirement of the original-model human race.

from http://www.frc.ri.cmu.edu/~hpm/project.archive/general.artic...

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by prostoalex on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:53PM (#6312720)
The problem with "general taxes" is that they don't fall from the skies.

In the economies with large percentage of makers and small percentage of moochers things work out decently, as the moochers category includes babies and elderly, so the work by makers is almost a social contract, a "thank you" to the society for support while being a baby, and a rainy day fund for one day when the maker himself will turn elderly.

Having a large population of working-age moochers violates the social contract, and creates incentives for the makers to optimize their revenue generation, if not quit altogether, Atlas Shrugged style.

The perverse incentives are apparent in post-Soviet economies, where under Soviet ruling government-owned enterprises frequently supported a vast infrastructure of company towns - everything from kindergartens to hospitals was included in the balance sheet of the local plant or factory.

Fast forward a few decades ahead, when the government-owned enterprises are now privately-owned, and typical pattern you see is profit-less plants and factories now selling their products at cost, avoiding profit sharing, to a Cyprus or Cayman Islands affiliate, with affiliate (incidentally controlled by large shareholders and top management) pocketing all the profits in tax-efficient manner.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by seiji on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:16PM (#6312795)
creates incentives for the makers to optimize their revenue generation

The quote in my other post up there says community pension is fueled by taxing corporations who generate income from virtually zero (or highly leveraged toward automation) human labor. So, yes, optimizing their revenue will increase the payments to the community pension fund which will help it grow larger.

Post-scarcaity will come right after everybody is automated out of a job, so we'll have zero employment and massive corporations. I see your point about backwards third world places being run by money warlords, but I'm not sure that's a rational outcome for modern society. Once you have empowered populations, those go away quickly.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by prostoalex on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:30AM (#6313578)
Taxing them on what? Profit? Sales?

The scheme I've described could very well apply to the US. Company A in China is doing the manufacturing with virtually zero human labor. It sells its product to Company B, located in a tax-free zone, which then resells the product to the US importer, Company C, which then sells it in the US. It just so happens that Company C makes a tiny margin on the profit it receives after buying from Company B, so it's happy to pay an exorbitant tax on that profit margin.

Company B is the one who makes a killing, but hey, it's in the tax-free zone, those lucky bastards.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by adisbladis on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:39PM (#6312474)
A thousand times yes! Automating away a lot of jobs as the economic system is now be disastrous, just think of Detroit at a very large scale.

"Wouldn't that be perfect if she could actually pursue her hobby?" is a very ignorant statement if you start to consider the implications of industry automation for all of the workers who have been automated away.

I believe that if we don't fundamentally change the economy through reform this will eventually lead to the next large revolution.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smacktoward on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:49PM (#6312509)
Yeah. Not a lot of laid-off auto workers doing backflips with joy because now they can devote more time their stamp collection.

The "hobbies" line is also infuriating because it practically drips with condescension. "I'm sure you have a hobby, don't you, dear? Of course you do! Why don't you go and spend some time on that while the grown-ups do the important work." All it's missing is a little pat on the head at the end.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by Houshalter on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:21PM (#6312813)
I think you are missing the point that people don't usually want to work doing these menial, easily automated jobs. They do it because they have to, to support themselves and their families.

If they could still support themselves or get paid, but not have to spend their day working, wouldn't they be better off?

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by unclebucknasty on Sunday September 01, 2013 @10:50PM (#6313228)
Wouldn't they be doing that now if they could? How does losing their jobs make their "hobbies" suddenly profitable?
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by ckannan90 on Monday September 02, 2013 @12:47AM (#6313498)
I think the argument about "hobbies" is a long term one, not one that applies to people who just got laid off. If there was no automation and everyone had to farm, nobody can pursue their "hobbies", because everyone has to work to meet their needs. At present, because of automation, less people have to farm. Because of that, people with a "hobby" of filmmaking can go make films, and other people with a "hobby" of watching films are able to spend their time (and money) watching those films. The argument is that automation eventually frees up society into doing less essential things and increases overall happiness.

Also hobbies is definitely not the right word here.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by unclebucknasty on Monday September 02, 2013 @07:12AM (#6314574)
>I think the argument about "hobbies" is a long term one, not one that applies to people who just got laid off.

I think that's the reality, but I am not sure that people like White from the article really acknowledge this. That is, he trivializes it by kind of offhandedly suggesting that it is good for people to have these new options open up as a result of losing their jobs.

But, in fact, what is required is a radical restructuring of our economy and society at large (including our ideas about work) in order to arrive at what he suggests. This is not a point that can simply be glossed over or assumed if he is being earnest or even remotely serious about addressing the automation issue.

Reminds me of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tO5sxLapAts. Step one is the automation of workers. Step three is this perfect utopian society, wherein we all just pursue our "hobbies".

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by Houshalter on Monday September 02, 2013 @03:26AM (#6313883)
We would need something like a basic income or some other way for people to support themselves without working. It's not reasonable for everyone to survive only by the value of their labor. Especially if automation makes it nearly worthless.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by unclebucknasty on Monday September 02, 2013 @06:54AM (#6314521)
Something like a basic income or other provision of basic needs will be unavoidable at some point. Automation is coming for virtually all of us, and we simply won't require nearly the number of people to produce what the world needs.

We have to some degree offset this with rabid consumerism, debt, and globalization. The latter in the sense of both opening new markets and the appeal of low wage workers usurping the appeal/cost of automation. But as the wages in these countries rise and technology continues to evolve while growing ever cheaper, even this can't stem the tide forever.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by wyager on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:52PM (#6312714)
When you replace someone with a machine, the cost of creating whatever object or service they worked to create goes down.

Either the customer gets a better deal (and has more money), the shareholders get more profit, or some combination of the two.

Either way, the customer buys more stuff or passes the benefits onto their customers, and the shareholders buy more stuff. All of a sudden, there is more demand for labor, and over time, the displaced humans get hired again.

You are invoking the luddite fallacy.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by pmichaud on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:04PM (#6312754)
This is a fantasy. There has to be diminishing returns at some point--there has to be a tipping a point where the Luddites are actually correct... it just wasn't 1811.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by wtallis on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:49PM (#6312892)
The Luddites were correct in recognizing that there was a problem to be addressed, but they weren't correct about how to deal with that problem. Halting technological progress and forgoing the economic prosperity it enables will never be the right answer for society as a whole - it's only a selfish and shortsighted response that gets triggered because our current society is unable to put that new prosperity to good use and instead leaves people out in the cold.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by pmichaud on Monday September 02, 2013 @03:25PM (#6316658)
Yeah, I agree with you -- the part I was saying the Luddites were right about is that at some point, technology obviates the need for everyone to be employed. I think that's a great thing, and I welcome it despite the enormously painful process it'll be to transition the economy.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by chiaro on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:33PM (#6312845)
The problem is that technology accelerating at a pace far greater than 1811, even though that was in the midst of the industrial revolution. Now, it makes perfect economic sense that automation of jobs on the cheap follows on to improving the economy, globally. However, this progress is associated with period of painful social adaptation.

The fear is not that demand for labor will decrease, but that the speed at which the labor force is upskilled will be outpaced by the progress of technology. So your factory and warehouse workers (who are already in a perilous financial situation) are unemployed, but more than that, their skills are no longer relevant. Increased demand for labor will not readily mesh with the skills of the existing workforce.

In the past, the gap has closed. But what if jobs are shed faster than their workers can transition to new ones? A scary, and not unrealistic prospect.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by ams6110 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:51PM (#6312710)
Why would people even be necessary in your view of the future?
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by polarix on Sunday September 01, 2013 @09:04PM (#6312936)
People are not necessary, of course. People simply exist.

It is human physicality and desire that creates necessity. When humans are freed from servitude under other humans, their own passions are able to flourish.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by Daniel_Newby on Sunday September 01, 2013 @09:38PM (#6313025)
Detroit collapsed because of the 1967 African insurrection, not automation. The engineers and executives fled to less lethal cities, where their automated car factories are thriving just fine.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by tartle on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:06PM (#6312575)
we'll need socialism much earlier than when all jobs are gone. the only problem is how to marry this transition with incentives for further technological development.

technological elites enjoying fruits of the economic growth, while the majority gets gradually reduced to TaskRabbits - that's really a disgusting picture...

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by diminoten on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:18PM (#6312611)
We'll need less people, or smarter people, not socialism.

Socialism, as a whole, leads to Bad Things. Sprinklings of socialism help and are good, but if you subscribe fully to any specific socialist doctrine, history shows your group will be harmed by it.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by vacri on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:33PM (#6312659)
Patent nonsense. The 'specific socialist doctrine' of Social Democracy is what the countries with the highest quality of life currently run.

If you mean 'communist', then say 'communist'.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smsm42 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:56PM (#6312913)
That's like saying Lance Armstrong took performance drugs, so if you want to bike like Armstrong then drugs is the best way to get there. In fact, for most people drugs would much faster get you into the hospital then into the Olympics. Same with socialism - some rich countries can take a lot of it and still maintain health, but less rich countries would just collapse.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by vacri on Sunday September 01, 2013 @09:27PM (#6312992)
Stop trying to shoehorn all of the kinds of socialism into the same bucket - it's a disease of modern American political discourse.

Not to mention that there isn't any system which survives your counterargument.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smsm42 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @10:35PM (#6313187)
There's only one kind of socialism - one that is based on forcibly taking the resources from producers and redistributing them by political whim. Everything else is a window dressing.

>>> Not to mention that there isn't any system which survives your counterargument.

If you can't distinguish good from harm or follow casual links - maybe. Fortunately, many people can.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by reginaldjcooper on Monday September 02, 2013 @12:52AM (#6313508)
> forcibly taking the resources from producers and redistributing them by political whim

The producers are actually the poor bastards working 40+ hours a week on the factory floor. The entities forcibly taking resources from them are the wealthy, by controlling the means of production, increasing CEO salaries, and colluding with legislators to provide more tax cuts and loopholes that only the wealthy can take advantage of. The political whim is that congressmen get more dollars from corporations after Citizen's United.

It's fucking ridiculous to be an Objectivist. You can continue to assert that poors are able to fight their way into the "producer" class by "not being lazy" or whatever. But the reality is when you can barely support your housing, food, transportation, and healthcare you don't have many rational options for aggressive advancement.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smsm42 on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:20AM (#6313558)
>>> The producers are actually the poor bastards working 40+ hours a week on the factory floor.

This is one kind of producers. But definitely not "the producers" - there are a lot of ways to produce value besides working on the factory floor. I suspect you yourself are paying your bills via one of such ways.

>>> The entities forcibly taking resources from them are the wealthy,

If they indeed do so, and you know about it, please call the police. I suspect, however, you do not understand what "forcibly" means, as wealthy people rarely resort to robbery - it is usually resort of the desperate and stupid.

It is true, however, that some wealthy employ other means of forcibly taking resources from other - namely, they benefit from various government programs, which forcibly extract resources from producers - ones working at the factories and in other places - and give it to some wealthy that are politically connected, claiming it is "for public good". Unfortunately, Supreme Court in infamous decision in Kelo vs. New London, decided it is completely legal to take private property and give it to another private person just because some government bureaucrat decided it is a good idea. In the very New London the case was about, they succeeded into converting a thriving residential neighborhood into a literal dump, spending tons of taxpayer money on the way. But I suspect for a socialist it is no problem at all.

>>> The political whim is that congressmen get more dollars from corporations after Citizen's United.

Barack Obama, who criticized this decision, spent $775 million on last election (http://www.cnbc.com/id/49550998/) outspending Romney by 75 mln. Romney is a rich man, and Obama is not exactly poor either, but this kind of money is not possible to come up without attracting donations, unless you want to have elections between Warren Buffett and Bill Gates each time.

Biggest political spenders are the unions (see here: http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list.php?type=A). So if you are worried about money in politics, that's where I would look. But then I don't see how you'd finance it... Oh, let me guess - instead of fatcats giving up the money voluntarily you want to tax the poor bastards working 40+ hours and get the money from them. Thanks, man, brilliant idea.

>>> It's fucking ridiculous to be an Objectivist.

I wouldn't know but if you say so...

>>> You can continue to assert that poors are able to fight their way into the "producer" class by "not being lazy" or whatever

No, I can't "continue" to assert that since I never started to assert it.

>>> But the reality is when you can barely support your housing, food, transportation, and healthcare you don't have many rational options for aggressive advancement.

When you have 1 welfare recipient for every 1.65 workers and the ratio is getting worse each year (http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2012-11-27/when-work-punished-...), and if you count government workers who are financed form taxes the ration is 1.25 - this means you only getting barely more than half of the value you're producing on average. If you don't produce a lot, this half indeed may not be enough to have very good life. However, for some people solution is for the state to take more and make the ratio worse. How this makes sense for them - I have no idea.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by lotsofcows on Monday September 02, 2013 @06:06AM (#6314390)
This is idiotic. Look at the Nordic countries. They rate highest for happiness, freedom of the press, etc. You're still suffering from the idiotic anti-communist propaganda from the cold war which ended over 20 years ago.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by worldsayshi on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:47PM (#6316211)
As a Swede having followed American politics (who doesn't these days) I can sort of see reasons to shun government influence. I guess you have to have a reasonable amount of trust in your government for a larger state apparatus to be acceptable. Not sure what would allow that but one bet is a political system that doesn't enforce a two party outcome. One crazy idea could be that a system that take a closer responsibility for wellfare issues also tend to encourage representatives that focus more on humanitarian values to be elected and such may be easier to put your trust in.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by vacri on Sunday September 01, 2013 @11:15PM (#6313301)
It is comments like this that make people think libertarianism is simple-minded twaddle.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smsm42 on Monday September 02, 2013 @12:42AM (#6313485)
I am impressed by the depth of your analysis. Obviously, anybody who says "twaddle" on the internet immediately wins the argument. Congratulations!
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by vacri on Monday September 02, 2013 @01:08AM (#6313532)
You called me a moron, but you did it in 'civil' language. Exactly what kind of deep analysis did you expect?
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smsm42 on Monday September 02, 2013 @02:26AM (#6313720)
No I didn't. But I must admit I didn't expect any depth of analysis from a socialist - if a socialist were capable of depth of analysis, he'd stop being a socialist. Socialism if a very natural feel-good idea, but it completely disintegrates as soon as one considers how it is actually supposed to work. That's why the only way it can exist is to be a parasite on capitalist systems in some rich country. Given to its own devices, socialism produces North Korea.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by diminoten on Monday September 02, 2013 @06:51PM (#6317654)
Average quality of life is not the goal of the US, nor should it be the goal of any country interested in creating wonders and advancing the whole of humanity.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by tartle on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:28PM (#6312643)
first of all, it depends what you define as socialism.

what seems more important, history shows that there are no Iron Laws Of History Written In Capital Letters. what we see is always an outcome of particular circumstances. like - "trying to establish a particular form of socialism (i would rather say this was communism, not socialism, but let's not open an argument here...) in an isolated, pre-capitalist country, that was recently destroyed by war, and has no democratic culture, produces shitty effects". that doesn't tell much about choices we have today.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by saraid216 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:37PM (#6312674)
If you define worker processes as workers, virtually all software is creating little socialist empires. This is basically a premise of jamesaguilar's comment.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by ams6110 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:56PM (#6312733)
We've never tried socialism where all the workers are replaced by automation. I suppose it could work, but I'm doubtful. People just aren't meant to live that way.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by tartle on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:16PM (#6312793)
people aren't "meant to" live in cities, use wheel, spend life in front of computer screens... but we're not hunters-gatherers any more, which suggests that what we are is far more determined by current form of society than innate "human nature". living a TaskRabbit life in the techno-capitalist dystopia is no more "natural" than some hypothetical form of democratic socialism - not to mention far less desirable for the majority.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by smsm42 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @08:44PM (#6312874)
If there would be no scarcity, who needs socialism? If there would be scarcity, there would be jobs in producing scarce resources and delivering them to whoever wants to consume them.

But if you are not happy with this, I can easily offer you a job creation program. Take two people. One would dig the ditch for 8 hours, the other would come next day and fill up the same ditch. Since you claim "jobs" are something we should pursue, this is a perfect example of jobs that can be created cheaply and abundantly. Of course, these jobs would provide zero value, but if you don't care about loss of value from employing people to do things that can be done with much higher value, then why should you care there? Just tax "the rich" and dig the ditch, and the jobs would be there forever.

Hint: google "broken window fallacy".

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by FreeFull on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:36PM (#6312457)
I think a big turning point in human history will be when computers will finally be capable of everything and more that a human can do.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by lukifer on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:54PM (#6312531)
If you want to talk about replacing jobs which are done more effectively by software, managing scarce resources to maximize utility and happiness seems like a pretty good candidate.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by straight_talk_2 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:53PM (#6312725)
Hard to understand what you mean. It's not like the current resource managers are trying to maximize happiness, but just lack efficiency. Just the opposite - the majority of ambitions, rich, powerful people in the world are putting tremendous efforts into extracting as much resources from the poor as possible.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by adisbladis on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:40PM (#6312476)
Considering how far the research into EEG has gotten the line between you and the computer will eventually blur out.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by ams6110 on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:53PM (#6312721)
I think it's more likely that there will be a massive war and the survivors will be peasants again.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by wheels on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:23PM (#6312417)
That's ok. The other animals in the zoo won't have to work either.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by benologist on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:35PM (#6312454)
You realize most of us are in that zoo too? There's nothing inherently magical about being able to make CRUD web sites and apps that protects us forever.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by wheels on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:58PM (#6312738)
My point, perhaps too veiled, was that as the amount of work that humanity is required to do approaches zero, so too does the likelihood that humanity remains the dominant species.
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by emiliobumachar on Sunday September 01, 2013 @09:02PM (#6312928)
Who could replace us? Why can the task of keeping them at bay not be automated?
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by monkeyspaw on Sunday September 01, 2013 @10:51PM (#6313231)
I think he may be referring to machine overlords. If the automated processes are what replace humans as the dominant life form, who will watch the automation?

I think the "dominant life form" thing is a bit of semantics. But I have found this entire thread very interesting.

It will be interesting to see what happens when humanity lacks scarcity. Research indicates that humans tend towards heirarchies, which are defined relative to neighbors. The "keeping up with the joneses" disease might be part of our core programming.

In a surplus society, I wonder what will substitute for status. Probably something much like our current system, I suppose.

Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by textminer on Monday September 02, 2013 @03:31AM (#6313902)
If you've never read this article in Jacobin magazine, I think you'd quite like it: http://jacobinmag.com/2011/12/four-futures/
Re:What did the tech CEO say to the worker he wanted to auto... by jamesaguilar on Monday September 02, 2013 @11:30AM (#6315588)
Instagram followers.

You think I'm joking, but really I am only sort of.