Re:We Need a Basic Income Guarantee
by notahacker on Sunday September 01, 2013 @04:13PM
(#6311945)
YCombinator sort of pays smart people BIs for a summer not as a reward for work but to ENABLE them to work, to great benefit (though not entirely unconditionally, obviously). When and why have we given up hope of expanding such concepts to all of society?
I think tech investment actually works better as an argument against expecting returns from giving people money to do what they want. Venture capitalists distribute capital to the most talented and motivated individuals in the entire country and have significant leverage when it comes to ensuring those elite recipients use that capital to generate positive financial returns.
And yet most VC funds still lose money.
Do we really think that taking money from people performing tasks people are willing to pay for and giving it to people performing tasks people are unwilling to pay for will be, on average, a winning bet for society? If it is, the misallocation of resources is probably too big a problem to be solved simply by throwing money at people.
It's one thing to subsidise public service and the risk of trying to produce something else. It's another thing to subsidise self-service and insulate people from the consequences of never producing anything.
Do we really think that taking money from people performing tasks people are willing to pay for and giving it to people performing tasks people are unwilling to pay for will be, on average, a winning bet for society? If it is, the misallocation of resources is probably too big a problem to be solved simply by throwing money at people.
It's one thing to subsidise public service and the risk of trying to produce something else. It's another thing to subsidise self-service and insulate people from the consequences of never producing anything.