News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rest of the Lenna Story by dalke on Sunday September 01, 2013 @06:49AM (#6309801)
I don't understand your comment. Why would this nude, of all of the nude images that exist, have any special importance in compression research? Other than historical reasons, of course.

For example, the colors and registration will be different than the original image, so it's not like a new scan will identically include the same pixels as the old scan. If a new scan is from the paper copy, then there might have been a change in the ink colors over time. If the new scan is from the negative then there's a difference between that color and what was printed.

You claim that "humans are hardwired to recognize nudity." Is that really true or is it a hypthosis? How was this tested? What is the signal difference between fully nude and partially nude? In the Lenna case, she is not completely nude - how will that confound the results? Does wearing a bikini affect the results? What about gloves? A cummerbund?

I grew up in a white-dominated culture and have more experience with white skin. I've noticed that it's easier for me to identify white skin than black skin. This suggests that recognition has a strong learned component. In those tests, how was the influence of that learned behavior disentangled?

Is the 'hardwired' recognition due specifically to nudity or is it to the transgression of cultural norms? That is, some cultures de-emphasize nudity as being something other than just a person without clothes. This is not generally true of US culture. I can conjecture that there is a hard-wired system to see if a person is following cultural norms, so in the US, nudity would stick out more than in cultures where casual nudity is more common.

Now that I think about it, any hardwired signal like this should be easy to test. Have an array of, say, 10x10 photographs, where one is nude and the others are wearing appropriately skin-tone clothes (fully dressed, partially dressed, etc). Then time how long it takes to find the nude person. This test can be done across multiple cultures pretty easily, so long as nude images are tolerated.

This is similar to the studies I've read about done on facial expressions, to show that some are very cross-cultural and thus likely more hard-wired, while others are not and thus more likely to be learned. For example, as your baseline reference, use a similar 10x10 grid but where one person is frowning while the others have a neutral face, and time how long it takes to find the frowning person.

Since it sounds quite simple to carry out, I figure it's been done, so if that's the sort of work you're referring to, can you kindly point it out? A Google search gets bogged down with references to algorithm for detecting nudity in images.

There are no comments on this comment yet.