News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by javajosh on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:59AM (#6306166)
Perhaps, in the end, the NSA has done us all a favor: they have shown us the fundamental insecurity of giving 3rd parties access to our data. With this move, Google and Microsoft clearly believe that there is demand for privacy, and understand that loss of trust has real, possibly severe, bottom-line implications. They act not of idealism, but out of fear.

The issue, of course, is that if someone wants to talk to me they need to connect with my physical equipment. In a perfect world, people would look me up with a simple IP address, and I'd have whatever services I wish to provide running on various ports from that IP. This machine could be my phone, or a computer I keep in my home. But what's funny is how the modern internet appears to conspire against this extraordinarily simple idea: the first problem is IPv4. There aren't enough IPs to give every internet-connected device a unique IP address, which means NAT, which is, AFAIK, fundamentally insecure when handling inbound traffic. The second is that virtually all internet providers forbid us, in their terms of service, from running "servers". Which brings us to this interesting syllogism:

1. Communication sent through third parties is not private.

2. All internet communication involves a third party

3. There is no private communication on the internet

Until the problems of IPv6 adoption and contractual restrictions on how you use your internet connection are solved, people do not have a viable alternative to using 3rd party hardware for communication over the internet.

Of course, if the "no fly list" is any precedent, the government argument will be something like, "then don't communicate with the internet".

Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by devx on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:52AM (#6306262)
I'm not sure I would go as far as saying it's impossible to have private communications on the Internet.

It's impossible right now for the masses, because they've decided they can trust these 3rd parties. So we never really put much thought into adopting "Trust No One" type of services. But having such services is probably doable, and now that we know these companies can't actually be trusted, perhaps we'll start using them.

Again, the main reason we didn't have private communications through 3rd parties, is because we thought we could trust those 3rd parties. But that has changed now.

Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by huhtenberg on Saturday August 31, 2013 @07:08AM (#6306502)
> they've decided they can trust these 3rd parties

Most of said masses don't even realize there's trust involved, leave along making a decision on whether to trust vendors or not. They just swallow what's free without much thinking.

Just look at something like the real-estate business. You'd think that realtors would appreciate how much private information is passing through their hands and that they would conform to the privacy protection laws they are typically bound with. And yet, every single one of these retards uses Gmail and routinely email forms stuffed to the brim with delicious personal info in plain text. How can you realistically expect the masses to do any better?

Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by samsquire on Saturday August 31, 2013 @08:32AM (#6306666)
Companies should not need to store data. They would instead make a connection to your data custodian or even your own machine and then use a 'personal data api' to fetch only the data they need.

That way you know what was given out and when and it's always up to date. They wouldn't be allowed to store it either. ( https://github.com/samsquire/ideas#92-personal-data-api )

Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by ptgloden on Saturday August 31, 2013 @09:24AM (#6306764)
Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by jonknee on Saturday August 31, 2013 @08:19AM (#6306636)
IP v4 or v6 still need routers between you and whoever you're talking to. It's a network, there will always be other parties involved.
Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by herf on Saturday August 31, 2013 @11:20AM (#6306998)
Yes, but you can usefully protect point-to-point communications using Diffie-Hellman or similar. You can't if you know someone is decrypting in the middle, even if they are using a common symmetric key that can be recovered by subpoena or NSL.
Re:Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests by joe_the_user on Saturday August 31, 2013 @07:01PM (#6308440)
Perhaps, in the end, the NSA has done us all a favor: they have shown us the fundamental insecurity of giving 3rd parties access to our data.

Let us not write now as if the Snowden leak effects are at their end. This is the start of whatever changes - good or bad, are going to come.

Especially, if the NSA gets the changes it wants from the situation, talking about the insecurity of a network would become illegal and bad security practices could be papered over. Security experts would be unable to speak openly and clever black hat hackers who kept their mouths shut could likely run rampant.