Re:Numenta open-sourced their Cortical Learning Algorithm
by volokoumphetico on Monday September 02, 2013 @06:51PM
(#6317658)
I have no clue about all that academic stuff, what's a good reading material for such things?
I didn't mean that Bayes nets are themselves naive--they're extremely good models for many use-cases. In fact, they're eventually ideal models for all use-cases, given enough training, since all ML models are ways to approximate Bayes' law, while Bayes nets just solve for Bayes' law directly. However, for being so generic, they have no embedded structure that allows them to efficiently learn/represent/compress data in any particular domain.[1]
When I have a Big Data problem, and I have a BNN library close to hand, I just throw it at a random subsampling and see what happens. This is what I mean by "naive": since it's a generic solution, you can try applying it to a problem before even studying the structure of the problem domain, and you might just detect a signal soon enough that you don't need to go any further.[2]
The rest of the machine-learning toolbox, then, is basically a set of models that you replace your BNN with when you have a model that hews closely to the structure of your data (in est, a set of screwdrivers for different kinds of screws.) The approximate model will get quicker training and clearer signals for that data, but not for just any data.
---
[1] Another way to say it: a Bayes-net implementation is to gzip as other ML models are to JPEG, MP3, etc. Bayes-nets can learn anything, but they can only learn it as well as the data can be used to model the data.
[2] People do use linear regression as the same kind of general-purpose tool, as you say--and linear classifier libraries are much easier to write, so you'll find them as "batteries included" in more math packages--but if you don't know whether the data is linearly separable, linear models aren't gonna give you even the slightest hint. A BNN is an extremely-inefficient, but completely-general probe.