News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 7 will bring the 'touch' interface to the masses.... by TomOfTTB on Thursday May 28, 2009 @11:08AM (#630320)
It's actually a massive leap backwards in usability. In the post linked to above I point out that the same action that takes one click with the mouse takes 2 clicks and 3 gestures with a multi-touch screen (worst case scenario obbviously). Moreover the increased range of motion in the shoulders and upper arms can cause muscle pain (I've actually done usability tests on this using a regular touch screen).

Again, I'm not saying it doesn't have limited use. Just that it won't revolutionize the UI of PCs (like it actually did for phones imho)

Re:Windows 7 will bring the 'touch' interface to the masses.... by anigbrowl on Thursday May 28, 2009 @12:43PM (#630526)
This sounds eerily reminiscent of the objections, including muscle pain, I heard to PCs going mouse+GUI in the 1990s (also yesterday here on HN :) ). Multi touch (which has been absent from this HN discussion but is present in Win7) allows many possibilities which are unavailable with a mouse and is what delivers the win.

Yes, interfaces will have to change and evolve - snapping will be more important than ever, a mouse is still more accurate for fine work (but so is a stylus) and it's going to take time to figure out how to communicate interface information when we can't necessarily rely on having a cursor. But we'll get there. Early WIMP systems were pretty lame too compared to what we enjoy now.