Re:Visualizations that make no sense
by sp332 on Friday August 30, 2013 @01:08PM
(#6302896)
Apple, at 34%, is almost as big as Google, at 89%.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The percentges add up to 130%, too.
Assuming a simple typo, where the 89 should be 59, the pie slices still look wrong to me. Looking at the relative sizes of the 4% and the 3% slices, that might be a rounding issue (could of instance be 3.7% and 3.3%), but the Apple and Android ones look too big to me.
Yeah, a typo can explain the total percentage issue.
But I don't see how wrong it would be to use the pie graph in such a way per se. IMHO, the foremost feature of pie graphs, the angle of sector, is kept.
Re:Visualizations that make no sense
by erichurkman on Friday August 30, 2013 @03:26PM
(#6303704)
It turns out you can have your pie and eat 30% of it, too.
Sorry, but I could not get it.
If Apple is at 34%, with Google/Android 89%, Windows Phone 4%, and Blackberry 3%, it would be a total of 130%, but 130% of what?
Oh! I think the point is: if you're comparing pieces to the whole, you should make a normal pie chart where the pieces are all on the same level. Stacking them up that way isn't really a pie chart at all, it's just a round bar chart.