News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by slg on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:21PM (#6296679)
I have to disagree with part of the premise. While the speech is copyrighted, that might not be the reason most people haven't read or seen the entirety of the speech. If schools really wanted to teach it, it would be well within fair use laws for them to show the whole thing. There are probably a variety of other reasons why you don't see this speech taught in schools.

First one that comes to mind is its length. Unlike the Gettysburg Address, this isn't some short speech that could be easily recited from memory.

Secondly, there is a lot of religious imagery in the speech. I could certainly imagine people objecting to having the speech presented in a secular school.

Finally and probably most importantly, what do speeches really teach us? They aren't particularly valuable outside of context. How many of the speeches listed here (http://www.americanrhetoric.com/top100speechesall.html) are really taught in school?

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by masklinn on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:48PM (#6296874)
> If schools really wanted to teach it, it would be well within fair use laws for them to show the whole thing.

No, not a chance. Even a few paragraphs would likely get them smashed, especially if they're the most interesting of the speech.

> First one that comes to mind is its length.

Have people stopped studying books or something?

> Secondly, there is a lot of religious imagery in the speech. I could certainly imagine people objecting to having the speech presented in a secular school.

I wouldn't.

> Finally and probably most importantly, what do speeches really teach us? They aren't particularly valuable outside of context.

It's quite obvious that the speech would be put in context by and used within civil rights study.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by hawkharris on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:06PM (#6296999)
Even a few paragraphs would likely get them smashed, especially if they're the most interesting of the speech.

I second this point. Under the Fair Use doctrine, courts consider not just the amount of text used, but the so-called substantiality of the excerpt. In other words, even a small portion of the text may not be fair use if it's especially iconic and representative of the whole.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by aioprisan on Thursday August 29, 2013 @03:57PM (#6298236)
I can tell you that in middle school at a public school in New Orleans, I had to read, summarize and write a paper reaction to the speech, as well as having watched the video.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by danielweber on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:53PM (#6296917)
Schools have successfully used copyrighted books all the time in literature classes without problems. You can't run it off yourself on the mimeograph machine but just go buy 30 copies and leave them in the classroom.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by vidarh on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:01PM (#6296969)
I was about to question whether or not you knew if this particular speech is actually available in its entirey anywhere that could be used as a source without potentially infringing copyright, but here it is available for download from the US National Archives:

http://www.archives.gov/press/exhibits/dream-speech.pdf

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by stonemetal on Thursday August 29, 2013 @03:01PM (#6297844)
Wouldn't distributing that file be considered copyright infringement? Just because you can legally access it there doesn't mean you have the right to redistribute. Sure you could direct your students there, but you can't do the copying yourself if I am not mistaken. Seems like picking up 20-30 copies off amazon would be easier.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by lotu on Thursday August 29, 2013 @07:12PM (#6299234)
The intended use in important. If a teacher distributes the speech in order to teach a lesson about it, it is very different than if a business man sell a book of the speech. Furthermore, the negative publicity from suing a teacher, using Martin Luther King Jr's speech to teach about civil rights should make any teacher completely safe from lawsuits.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by solistice on Thursday August 29, 2013 @08:43PM (#6299547)
Possible publicity is a pretty weak protection compared to actual legality, and I can't imagine a regular teacher (I'm excluding highly idealistic teachers, but those are few and far strewn) would risk their job illegally distributing those texts/videos, if there is even a quanta of possibility that that happens.

Teachers aren't the idealized constructs they often use to teach.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by masklinn on Thursday August 29, 2013 @03:49PM (#6298193)
> Schools have successfully used copyrighted books all the time in literature classes without problems.

That is a completely different issue, classrooms have a specific exception (USC title 17 chapter 1 § 110 (1)) which allows "performance or display of a work by instructors or pupils in the course of face-to-face teaching activities of a nonprofit educational institution, in a classroom or similar place devoted to instruction".

The issue at hand here is that textbook publishers can't (or won't) include the speech or even major excerpts of it. And although a teacher can buy the speech DVD and play it, it's not a very good support to study the speech.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by DannyBee on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:56PM (#6297807)
They have also been successfully sued a number of times for course packets, so they tend to be very careful.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by danielweber on Thursday August 29, 2013 @04:57PM (#6298566)
So buy it. The same way they would study Shel Silverstein poems.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by chimeracoder on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:03PM (#6296981)
Of course they can. That's not the issue. The issue is that textbook publishers cannot (or will not) include the speech in their books, because then they would have to pay royalties (and indirectly pass along those costs to the schools).

Furthermore, use of the video is much more heavily controlled by the King estate.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by danielweber on Thursday August 29, 2013 @04:56PM (#6298562)
Schoolbooks are full of stuff that is copyrighted. The photos explicitly are.

We still have Norton's Antologies, right? Many of those are 100% filled with copyrighted works they need to pay royalties on. And they do. And everything works out just fine.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by 001sky on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:07PM (#6297452)
because then they would have to pay royalties

The issue is the price not the payment per-se.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by dvmmh on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:01PM (#6296971)
That's assuming you CAN buy the book/speech.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by travisp on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:50PM (#6297312)
You can buy it in written form, audio form, or DVD form and you can license it for placement in a book.

Here is even an illustrated form for children with a CD: http://amzn.com/0375858873

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by gnaritas on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:56PM (#6297362)
> mimeograph machine

Showing your age? :)

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by cgore on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:29PM (#6297621)
In 2003-ish, while I was getting my BS, the professor passed out some of those funny-smelling purple sheets. I hadn't seen them since probably second grade (mid-1980's). Apparently both the copiers were broken, but there was still an old mimeograph sitting in the corner, she tried it, and it still worked.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by danielweber on Thursday August 29, 2013 @04:58PM (#6298570)
Wow, I said mimeograph entirely as a joke, I didn't think anyone had used them this century.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by unclebucknasty on Saturday August 31, 2013 @08:14AM (#6306623)
So funny. I can instantly recall that smell to this day.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by warfangle on Thursday August 29, 2013 @08:00PM (#6299399)
> I wouldn't.

Neither would I. We studied the book of Ruth in an ancient literature course in high school, along with Gilgamesh, et al. It was very interesting to read them in that context.

The effect of religion is inseparable from the course of history. It's possible to approach it from a non-theistic context.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by girvo on Friday August 30, 2013 @05:56AM (#6300932)
I did Study of Religion at a Catholic private school. We studied other religions (Buddhism, Islam, and I chose to spend a year studying The Salvation Army) in a non-theistic and academic context. It was mind expanding, and a major reason I am now an atheist.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by jmduke on Thursday August 29, 2013 @05:28PM (#6298745)
I read and listened to the speech in both high school and middle school in Virginia, for what it's worth.

Even now, its so surprising to me that such a pivotal part of my nation's history is such a great piece of oratory. The entire thing is just so incredibly mellifluous.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by yeahbutbut on Friday August 30, 2013 @08:59AM (#6301439)

    >> If schools really wanted to teach it, it would be well within fair use laws for them to show the whole thing.
    >
    > No, not a chance. Even a few paragraphs would likely get them smashed, especially if they're the most interesting of the speech.
    >
Actually we had to memorize a significant portion of the speech for my eighth grade AP English class, in addition to watching the speech, and talking about the context. This was part of a larger section on civil rights coordinated with our History lessons.

I'm not a lawyer, but I'm fairly certain that educational programs are allowed to do whatever they want wrt. copyright as long as they can show educational value and aren't directly profiting off of reproducing the copyrighted work.

http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl102.html

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by masklinn on Friday August 30, 2013 @09:12AM (#6301495)
> I'm not a lawyer, but I'm fairly certain that educational programs are allowed to do whatever they want wrt. copyright

You're wrong. Educational programs have a specific exemption for performing or displaying lawfully acquired copyrighted works in a classroom setting: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/110 but that's the extent of it, they most definitely are not allowed to reproduce copyrighted work whether profiting of it or not.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by dllthomas on Friday August 30, 2013 @09:00AM (#6301447)
If that were true, there wouldn't be a market for textbooks.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by yeahbutbut on Friday August 30, 2013 @09:06AM (#6301472)
Not necessarily. The material teachers distribute to classes come out of their budget (ink and paper aren't free). And the time taken to compile an entire course from scratch would not be insignificant.

The copyrighted works we were shown and given access to in class were supplements to the textbooks we were using.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by msluyter on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:14PM (#6297498)
Pretty sure we read this in my senior english class in high school. (Under the general topic of persuasion/argument/rhetoric.)
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by dalke on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:56PM (#6297364)
Good points. I disagree with more parts of the premise than you do. It says: "Documentaries can only include small, five-second clips. Take a moment and ask the people sitting near you if they’ve ever heard the opening lines:"

I am one such. In fact, I heard it just the other day. It starts at 46:04 of http://www.democracynow.org/2013/8/28/50_years_after_march_o... .

Democracy Now also has lengthy excerpts from MLK's "Beyond Vietnam" speech and his "I Have Been to the Mountain Top" (See http://www.democracynow.org/2012/1/16/special_dr_martin_luth... ) and likely more speeches if you search the archives.

(It may be that since a news show isn't a documentary, it is one of the exceptions implied in 'most circumstances.')

I agree with you: the reason why 'ask the people sitting near you' works is likely more because - as you say - most people don't listen to speeches or watch documentaries with speeches in them.

I disagree with your religious imagery observation somewhat, because that speech doesn't include much in the way of religious imagery which needs to be explained. Looking through the copy at http://www.archives.gov/press/exhibits/dream-speech.pdf , I see:

- references to the Gettysburg Address ("Five score years ago .. this hallowed spot")

- religious references ("captivity" can refer to the Babylonian captivity; "The whirlwinds of revolt" sounds like a reference to a verse from Hosea; "every valley shall be exalted ... all flesh shall see it together" is Isaiah 40:4-5.)

- Shakespeare ("This sweltering summer of the Negro's legitimate discontent" is a reference to Richard III)

- perhaps Newton? ("meeting physical force with soul force" sound like "equal and opposite force")

- The Declaration of Independence ("We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal")

- the 1831 song "My Country 'Tis of Thee" (some 17 lines are a reference to the song)

This doesn't sound like any more use of religious imagery than other texts often taught in school. "To Kill a Mockingbird", for example, starts with a Methodist fleeing religious intolerance in England, and has an scene where the white children Scout and Jem go to Calpurnia's black church for a Sunday service.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by krschultz on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:20PM (#6297089)
I really don't think references to religion are a problem. My AP English class read parts of the Bible itself - because it has significant literary and historic importance even if you don't view it as a religious text. This is in a secular public school in a very liberal state only recently. Nobody objected, because if you start going down that road, you will have to throw out pretty much everything written before 1800.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by learc83 on Thursday August 29, 2013 @04:16PM (#6298344)
Yeah Sinners in the Hand of an Angry God was in my textbook in American lit (~2001).
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by zaphar on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:48PM (#6297758)
Many schools do start down that road. Having the Bible in your classroom even for purely non religious reasons has gotten people in trouble before and many schools just don't want the hassle so they outright ban it.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by masklinn on Thursday August 29, 2013 @03:44PM (#6298158)
Do you have sources for that?
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by unclebucknasty on Saturday August 31, 2013 @08:21AM (#6306642)
It's always been odd to me that freedom of religion is so frequently interpreted as denial of its existence. At some point, the extent to which public society goes to avoid acknowledging it becomes kind of silly. And, of course, when taken too far, it actually infringes on true freedom for those who practice.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by teh_klev on Thursday August 29, 2013 @10:21PM (#6299872)
Indeed, there's a world of difference between reading religious texts or listening to material that may make reference to religious matter, for the purpose of comprehension or understanding historical context etc, and it being used for proselytism.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by ChuckMcM on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:43PM (#6297252)
There was a PBS Documentary, "Eyes on the Prize" which we bought on DVD as part of our home school curriculum. Then it was taken off the market as a dispute arose between the King family estate[1] and PBS. The King family gave only enough copy right to show the program on PBS, once. And any other use was not sanctioned, we loaned our copy to the high school so that they could show it to their students.

It was such a remarkably egregious thing, I was amazed that more people weren't up in arms about it.

[1] http://www.current.org/2010/03/eyes-on-the-prize-triumphs-ov...

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by nkurz on Thursday August 29, 2013 @11:29PM (#6300096)
I supported Downhill Battle's copywrite civil disobedience, and hosted viewings in my home at the time. I'm glad to see that an official version has been released, and that hopefully it will not be forgotten. Out of curiousity, was your copy the $40 "Home Version" (http://www.shoppbs.org/product/index.jsp?productId=3999340) or the $260 "Educator's Version" (http://teacher.shop.pbs.org/product/index.jsp?productId=2445...) that includes licensing for classroom use?
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by mratzloff on Thursday August 29, 2013 @04:30PM (#6298422)
Ah, it's back on sale! Thanks for the link, I didn't know they had put it back up.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by Spooky23 on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:55PM (#6296929)
It is the reason. The King family controls the rights to the speech and will sue people deemed to have violated those rights.

See: http://www.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/ops/19989079.MAN.pdf

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by mistercow on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:48PM (#6297754)
>Secondly, there is a lot of religious imagery in the speech. I could certainly imagine people objecting to having the speech presented in a secular school.

At my (public) high school (10ish years ago), we had "character education", and one of the "character words" we had (there was a new one each month) was "respect for the Creator", which is:

A) Actually four words.

B) Insanely, crazy religious.

I assure you that the religious angle is not why this is not presented in full in schools.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by adcoelho on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:41PM (#6296824)
I read the speech in English class when studying different types of writing assignments. We examined it for its structure rather than its content. Studying speeches may prove valuable when preparing oral presentations for instance.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by 3minus1 on Thursday August 29, 2013 @03:11PM (#6297920)
I also read it, in 10th grade English. I think we analyzed it's rhetorical effectiveness.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by cglee on Thursday August 29, 2013 @01:54PM (#6297349)
A secular education doesn't mean it's devoid of religious literature. On the contrary, it probably means you get to explore religious texts from a variety of cultures and religions.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by cydonian_monk on Thursday August 29, 2013 @03:52PM (#6298213)
That was the case in my school. We covered (nearly) every major religion, how it formed, how it spread, impact on the societies involved, etc. Did it upset parents? Undoubtedly. But it was a non-issue, unlike the ban on soft drinks (which was blown so far out of proportion it became comical).
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by smsm42 on Thursday August 29, 2013 @08:25PM (#6299475)
>>> I could certainly imagine people objecting to having the speech presented in a secular school.

When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.

I wonder how they deal with that religious imagery. Or they neglect to mention that unimportant document altogether?

I can understand when people object to school propagandizing religion or requiring some religious rites or observances from non-religious people. But completely removing a part of history because religion is mentioned there or certain figure was, in fact, a religious man? That's just insane, and anti-religious bigot would be as bad as a religious one.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by moocowduckquack on Thursday August 29, 2013 @09:50PM (#6299783)
"First one that comes to mind is its length. Unlike the Gettysburg Address, this isn't some short speech that could be easily recited from memory."

You are probably not learning it for recital to prove how clever you are, you are presumably reading it for study and analysis.

"Secondly, there is a lot of religious imagery in the speech. I could certainly imagine people objecting to having the speech presented in a secular school."

On what grounds? On that basis you couldn't have US school textbooks with translations of the letters of Christopher Columbus in them -

"In conclusion, to speak only of what has been accomplished on this voyage, which was so hasty, their Highnesses can see that I will give them as much gold as they may need, if their Highnesses will render me very slight assistance; presently, I will give them spices and cotton, as much as their Highnesses shall command… and slaves, as many as they shall order, and who will be from the idolaters. I believe also that I have found rhubarb and cinnamon, and I shall find a thousand other things of value, which the people whom I have left there will have discovered…

This is enough. And thus the eternal God, Our Lord, gives to all those who walk in His way triumph over things which appear to be impossible, and this was notably one. For, although men have talked or have written of these lands, all was conjectural, without ocular evidence. ... So that, since Our Redeemer has given the victory to our most illustrious King and Queen, and to their renowned kingdoms, in so great a matter, for this all Christendom ought to feel delight and make great feasts and give solemn thanks to the Holy Trinity, with many solemn prayers for the great exaltation which they shall have in the turning of so many peoples to our holy faith, and afterwards for the temporal benefits, because not only Spain but all Christendom will have hence refreshment and gain."

- The conclusion to his letter to King Ferdinand of Spain.

http://amhist.ist.unomaha.edu/module_files/Columbus%20to%20F...

"Finally and probably most importantly, what do speeches really teach us? They aren't particularly valuable outside of context."

What someone in the past said. Is part of learning about stuff, which is the context.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by Steko on Thursday August 29, 2013 @09:59PM (#6299808)
"On that basis you couldn't have US school textbooks with translations of the letters of Christopher Columbus in them"

I don't know what your point is, most school textbooks don't include Colombus' letters either. And it's not that history textbooks can't include religious content but the more religious content there is the less likely you're going to see it in a secular textbook, grandparent is precisely right.

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by moocowduckquack on Thursday August 29, 2013 @10:08PM (#6299833)
How on earth do you think you can you avoid including religious content in history textbooks, irrespective of the secularity of the school? You'd have to cut nearly all of it.

Besides I would have thought that a secular school would be one where you would see the widest range of religious content when studying history, as it would be less likely to be biased in favour of any religion in particular.

edit - the following is from a US lesson plan on Christopher Columbus for history teachers in public schools;

"In this unit, students will work with primary source documents written by Christopher Columbus around the time of his voyage to the New World, and with secondary source documents written at a later date. They also have a chance to write their own secondary source material in this unit. Using both primary and secondary source documents within a single unit gives students an opportunity to see the difference between these two types of documents. You may wish to have students work alone or in small groups to read and interpret these documents. Groups could be based on areas of interest (especially for analyzing the scholarly documents), or could allow students with stronger reading skills to help others work through the source documents."

and

"The desire to bring Christianity to native peoples was essential to European exploration. It is a topic that cannot be ignored in discussions of Columbus"

http://edsitement.neh.gov/lesson-plan/what-was-columbus-thin...

Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by Steko on Friday August 30, 2013 @07:41AM (#6301193)
It helps if people actually read, no one is saying all religious content is off limits or should be disallowed.
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by devx on Thursday August 29, 2013 @02:44PM (#6297729)
At the very least it "chilled" the usage of that speech, because it's not very clear whether they will be targeted by the owners or not (they probably would be, which is reason enough not to use it, even if they are in the "right" to use it).
Re:Why You’ve Never Read “I Have A Dream” by lowmagnet on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:47PM (#6296869)
I disagreed with its title, because I have read it.