News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: reCaptcha isn't stopping spam, what should I do? by notlisted on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @10:33PM (#6293920)
I've had a lot of success by including a field called email in my form, hiding it with css so humans cannot see it, and whenever a submission/login request/post is received, I merely check to see if the email field has been set.

If so, I know it wasn't a human that submitted the post - they could not see it - whilst automated spam tools seemingly cannot resist entering something in that field. I emailed suspect postings to myself with IP address info to add them to an IP block-list later, but showed them a fake "success" page or a "your post has been selected for moderation" page. The latter turned out to be more effective as it resulted in fewer repeated attempts.

I removed the annoying reCaptcha code altogether as a test, and never had to reinstate it. Real users hated the reCaptcha thing anyhow.

Re:Ask HN: reCaptcha isn't stopping spam, what should I do? by Prefinem on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @11:45PM (#6294123)
User's hating the captcha has been my biggest fear with this. I will definitely look into the hidden email field as well. That seems more user friendly. Do you hide the element with css or some other way?
Re:Ask HN: reCaptcha isn't stopping spam, what should I do? by munimkazia on Thursday August 29, 2013 @05:08AM (#6294950)
This is actually pretty smart. Love the idea. I think I am going to give this a shot soon.