News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by dalek_cannes on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @12:20AM (#6287999)
> We produce vastly more, but work as much as ever. Back in the 60s the sentiment was that 21st century Americans might have 10 hour work weeks.

Isn't that because we now have a very large semi-parasitical managerial class that we need to support? It's almost a retreat into feudalism. Doubt anybody saw that coming.

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by VLM on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @09:23AM (#6289750)
One interesting interpretation is the ratio of people with desk jobs consisting of 50% (or higher) fooling around vs sweaty manual labor jobs has led to the average American perhaps only working 20 hours a week right now.

Think of pointless meetings, smoke breaks, soda breaks, talking about sports, life, hobbies, debating/complaining, talking politics, talking about TV shows, online shopping, keeping up with twitter/FB/Linkedin, Hacker News, the average cubie dweller probably only puts in 10-20 hours a week of actual work right now.

"Everyone knows" the guy who's forced to put in 60 hours at the office who spends 50 of those hours on FB / Reddit / talking about football, etc.

There's a Russian proverb about we pretend to work and they pretend to pay us.

If you define work as "hours spend on premises" then no one has worked as many hours as Americans do today since the early 1900s. If you define work as actually doing something productive, well, thats a whole nother ball game.

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by coldtea on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @09:55PM (#6293818)
>One interesting interpretation is the ratio of people with desk jobs consisting of 50% (or higher) fooling around vs sweaty manual labor jobs has led to the average American perhaps only working 20 hours a week right now.

For actual work, maybe even less.

But not having pocession of your body for 8-12 hours every day in exchage for a pay-check, is work too. Even if you just sit there and "do nothing".

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by gosub on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @03:23AM (#6288479)
No, it's because if a worker works 8h/day, and produces X, given a new technology that double his productivity, he is now expected to still work 8h/day, and produce 2X.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by gosub on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @03:31AM (#6288510)
And this, incidentally, is why there never will be "more jobs". Occupation is production over productivity. With an increment of productivity, you can ramp up production up to mass-production keeping the same occupation level. But markets get saturated, so you can't increase production indefinitely. Still, productivity, with automation and robotization and renewable energy sources, could be make practically infinite. But for the reason in the post above, work is not distributed in the work-force.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @10:01AM (#6289959)
But his pay remains X, while the CEO, VP team and shareholders keep 100% of the extra value.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by coldtea on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @09:57PM (#6293825)
Or actually goes down in actual bying value (as it has since the 70s).
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by Houshalter on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @02:19AM (#6288299)
That doesn't make a lot of sense. People don't work because they want to support someone else, they work because they want to support themselves.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by legutierr on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @03:11AM (#6288446)
However, if the rise in average incomes in the US over the past thirty or forty years were more evenly distributed among the working population, and not just concentrated at the top, many people would probably choose to work much less.

People work to support themselves, but I would wager that most would work less to support themselves if they could earn enough to do so.

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by contingencies on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @03:07AM (#6288431)
That comment is at once so amazingly wrong and quintessentially American, it's almost a work of art.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by Houshalter on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @09:30PM (#6293744)
Right because people obviously work for the sole purpose of supporting their manager. Not to feed themselves or anything, that's silly American stuff.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by qu4z-2 on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @09:50PM (#6293797)
What about building nice things, or making the world a better place? (Although that's probably truer of the hacker profession than some others)
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by cpfohl on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @07:48AM (#6289235)
Can I assume you have neither spouse nor child? I'd argue that once those things come along you might disagree with your own statement. You could probably rephrase it so I agreed with you, though: "People don't work because they want to support their boss's high standard of living, they work because they want to improve their own."

Is that what you meant?

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by dclowd9901 on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @02:28AM (#6288323)
He's trying to make the case that there's some great conspiracy to keep people employed in jobs that shouldn't exist.

I suppose he'll next tell us that the rich are "job creators."

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by solistice on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @06:58AM (#6289067)
I'm not sure what you think job creators are. Is it some kind of medal you get when you employ someone? Do you loose it if you fire them? What kind of conditions constitutes employing? Do I get to be a job creator if I give you a dollar for explaining your point?

Job providers, I get why those are important. Not everyone wants to be bothered with the business side of living, along with its risks. I can actually see how that division of labour and responsibilities aids both sides of the equation.

But if you count self-employment, there's job providers on every rung of the social ladder. The chinese guy selling chua'r on the street is a job provider, just as much as the multimillion entrepreneur employing thousands of people. So it becomes senseless to say that one wealth bracket supplies jobs, and another one doesn't.

And then there's "job creation", which seems like a meaningless metric if you don't factor in loss of jobs, current amount of jobs, unemployment, etc. And you seriously want to pin that metric down on a single group?

By the way, if the take the logic further, and look at who's implicated in major job destruction (layoffs), it's us. Hackers. I'm going from the Systems optimization definition here, and when you optimize away a part of a system, someone's bound to get fired. Your packaging machine eliminated 5 packaging workers. Your fiber optic cable eliminated 50 post office workers.

They're being added, somewhere.

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by zanny on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @08:12AM (#6289348)
I hate when the discussion devolves into putting flesh bodies into 40 hour a week boxes to repeat some repetitive task.

The truth behind job scarcity or not is supply and demand. Period. If there is no demand for yours, or someone elses labor, there is no job. No wealth redistribution will change that. The arguments behind why, though, the concentration of wealth was bad, is that the wealthy have fewer demands they want met relative to the entirety of everyone else. A more prosperous majority gnerates tremendous demand, millionaires generate limited and specific demand.

But you don't escape the reality of having a supply of something trying to meet the demand for it. There just isn't much demand for a lot of labor types, and producitivity multipliers in technology lets that demand be met with much less workforce supply, which means tremendous economic efficiency gains.

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by contingencies on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @11:15AM (#6290502)
I hate when the discussion devolves into putting flesh bodies into 40 hour a week boxes to repeat some repetitive task.

Me too. Apparently it's primarily a mass-media political posturing tool for the (fearing-to-be-)disenfranchised classes (ie. a huge proportion of the population).

producitivity multipliers in technology lets that demand be met with much less workforce supply, which means tremendous economic efficiency gains.

... and loads of people shifted to the bottom of the opportunity barrel, save for states with some semblance of social welfare (ie. not the US).

Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by zanny on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @04:14PM (#6292337)
That just requires a realization that few people can provide the necessary resources and goods to maintain the rest. We avoid that realization, hence elsewhere in this comment thread discussions of 50%+ office jobs and only working 10 hours of your 40 hour shift come into play. I guess it plays counter to the rugged individualism model of thinking (that, let us be honest, wealthy business owners love because it creates surplus labor supply on a cultural basis rather than a fiscal need) even though we have had 1% of the population working as farmers for 30 years providing all the crops we eat, even when our crops are grossly inefficient like beef.
Re:Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be lik... by contingencies on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @05:19PM (#6292752)
Well, I don't think anyone should choose for 'the rest'.

With regards to your comment on 1% of people being farmers and that being adequate, here's some fast facts about the US agricultural industry:

(1) 300 million people in the US, and the US can sustainably produce food for only 130 million of them. (recentish UN estimate I believe)

(2) Many US farms are net energy consumers, ie. they burn more energy in production than they give people in food.

Second, the earth will actually produce enough to support many humans using no humans (ie. "let the plants grow back, stop maintaining the concrete, stop unsustainably exploiting and poisoning the environment"). It just requires us to be a bit more in tune with the environment (eg. decentralize, consume in-season, eat less meat, start sharing a bit more).

Interesting times.