News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by swamp40 on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @01:55PM (#6285023)
How would you explain why birds raised in isolation can still build nests? And sing the songs of their species?

I would propose that it is possible that some animal "instincts" are really inherited memories from their ancestors.

And that if we look hard enough and deep enough, we may find similar human "instincts".

Have you ever seen a baby with a fear of spiders? Whose parents swear the child has never even seen a spider before?

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by chc on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:00PM (#6285055)
The leap from "Instincts are inherited" to "This is because memories are inherited" is the furthest thing from science you could possibly get.
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by foobarbazqux on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:19PM (#6285167)
Any falsifiable hypothesis is scientific.
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by chc on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:22PM (#6285196)
And this hypothesis presents no testable predictions. It's more or less equivalent to "A wizard did it."
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by foobarbazqux on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:30PM (#6285242)
> I would propose that it is possible that some animal "instincts" are really inherited memories from their ancestors.

I think that's pretty testable, just find a way to condition the ancestors and see if the conditioning shows up in the offspring.

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by chc on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:57PM (#6285400)
But it's obvious that he's not saying all memories are inherited (at least, not in a way we can detect), so a negative result is not disproof.
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by foobarbazqux on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @03:31PM (#6285657)
A negative result disproves it for the specific kind of memory, e.g. fear of spiders, but you're right that the disproof can't be straightforwardly transferred to claims about other kinds of memories.

The hypothesis is so unlikely given what we know about the brain and reproduction that we'll assume false by default for all memories. Thus the onus is on the experimenter to provide a positive result for some case and also demonstrate that there isn't something else going on.

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by swamp40 on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:23PM (#6285203)
My views reflect Darwin's. Is he scientific enough for you?

May we not suspect that the vague but very real fears of children, which are quite independent of experience, are the inherited effects of real dangers and abject superstitions during ancient savage times? - Charles Darwin, A Biographical Sketch of an Infant (1877)

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by tristanj on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @05:29PM (#6286427)
The quote you picked doesn't fully support your view - if you read the full quote, Darwin suggests that such inherited effects start to appear at one point in one's life and disappear afterwards. If instincts were truly passed on as memories, then they should be present throughout life and not appear when such evolutionary adaption is needed. This conflicts with evolutionary developmental psychological theory, which suggests that people face different survival adaptive problems at various points of their lifetime. For example, problems of survival as an infant must occur before problems of mating. Mating must predictably occur before parenting, and likewise before grand-parenting. From this, we expect certain "instincts" to appear and disappear as adaptive problems change. This is known to be true in infants: two examples are an infant's ability to swim (which disappears after 6 months) and also the Moro reflex, a potentially lifesaving reflex that occurs while falling. If these were "memories" and not instincts, then they would not appear so rapidly nor so consistently. There's quite a few examples of similar instincts listed on Wikipedia [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primitive_reflexes

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by saalweachter on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @08:28PM (#6287263)
1. Darwin was pre-DNA. His guesses on the mechanisms of evolution aren't very relevant to the modern understanding.

2. Darwin was not infallible. We pick our scientific heroes because of their ability to advance science, to see farther than others, and be remarkably right given the information they had. Our heroes were still wrong about a lot of things, both outside there areas of expertise and inside their areas of expertise. For instance, Newton was the foremost expert on light of the day, and advanced our understanding of optics greatly, but he thought it was a particle. He was wrong, and we do him no honor by believing it a particle in his name.

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by swamp40 on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @11:28AM (#6290567)
I'm fairly certain that there is a lot about DNA that we do not yet fully understand.

Plenty of room for spider fears and bird songs.

Apparently the word "memory" is unsettling to some, but it still seems appropriate to me.

If DNA can grow 10,000 different regions of a brain, why is it unreasonable to think that it could also pre-populate some of those regions with patterns that we can access as memory?

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by pedrocr on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @06:08AM (#6288903)
>He was wrong, and we do him no honor by believing it a particle in his name.

Do you mean he's wrong because light is a particle and a wave[1]?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave%E2%80%93particle_duality

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by saalweachter on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @09:45AM (#6289873)
Yes.

It would probably be better to say "just a particle and not a also a wave".

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by chc on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @03:37PM (#6285708)
Darwin has the "Instincts are inherited" part, but not the "This is because memories are inherited" part, which is what I was questioning.
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by saraid216 on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @01:31AM (#6288186)
> Is he scientific enough for you?

saalweacher has started to cover why, but I'd like to emphasize a request: never ask this question sincerely again.

Darwin is a reasonably valid authority, but it's not because he's "scientific". People are not scientific. Processes are scientific. People who enact scientific processes are scientists. Conclusions drawn from scientific processes are science. "Scientific" should never refer to people.

I think you and Darwin are probably right. That's a long, long, long way from being proven right, though, and it's a huge mistake to assume so from a bit of poetry that Darwin speculated with.

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by swamp40 on Friday August 30, 2013 @02:12PM (#6303286)
You are right, of course.
Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @11:37AM (#6290643)
> My views reflect Darwin's. Is he scientific enough for you?

An opinion doesn't turn into a scientific proposition because it matches the speculation of someone who also did significant scientific work.

The whole point of science is that it is method, independent of who is doing it.

Re:Memories of positive associations get written onto DNA by swamp40 on Friday August 30, 2013 @02:14PM (#6303298)
Yes, I concur. It was a poorly constructed sentence, as well as baiting.