Re:On Lisp
by agumonkey on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:23AM
(#6276136)
How large are these s-exp ? Lisp is unreadable when nested too much (I'm starring at an xml->s-exp dump and I don't even wanna try to read it), but usually lisp code and data tend to be factored into little combinators and separated specific functions. If you can, try to split them.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:On Lisp
by dpritchett on Monday August 26, 2013 @07:59AM
(#6276448)
Here's a link to an example of that coping strategy from some bad Clojure I wrote last night [1]. I sometimes use an accumulation of lets for a similar effect, but only when describing simpler transformations.
The lets might look like so (warning- silly example):
(defn n-squared-over-two-plus-three-as-str [n]
(let [squared (* n n)
halved (/ squared 2.0)
added (+ halved 3)]
(str added)))
> (n-squared-over-two-plus-three-as-str 1)
"3.5"
Sure, I could've just done this as a deeply-nested structure: > ((fn [n] (str (+ 3 (#(/ % 2.0) (* n n))))) 1)
"3.5"
... but it's harder to read, debug, and reason about. You wouldn't do that in a non-functional language either! I suppose the tolerance for deep nesting is different for different programmers.[1] https://github.com/dpritchett/cloball/blob/62300d31666ab1261...
That looks like a good place to use the arrow macro http://clojuredocs.org/clojure_core/clojure.core/-%3E
Re:On Lisp
by dpritchett on Monday August 26, 2013 @11:10AM
(#6277522)
Yep, that's what the link in my original post was hoping to demonstrate. I find rolling up a few lets one after the other more natural in some other situations.
Re:On Lisp
by dpritchett on Monday August 26, 2013 @11:59AM
(#6277867)
Although I'm second-guessing my let example now. Lets are great for assigning names to your building blocks, but I don't really like using them to obscure my processing flow as above. Perhaps this would be a better compromise:
(defn example [n]
(let [square #(* % %)
halve #(/ % 2.0)
add3 #(+ % 3)]
(-> n square halve add3 str)))
> (example 1)
"3.5"If the function name or docstring is descriptive enough, I'd just go for
(defn square-halve-add3-to-string [n]
(-> n
(#(* % %))
(/ 2.0)
(+ 3)
str))