I interpreted tjoff's argument to be that the average Tor exit node is more malicious than any of the other average ways for proxies to be dangerous. In other words, yes coffee shops could be dangerous, but they are most often safe, whereas if you're getting routed through a bunch of exit nodes over a period of time (is that even how it works?) you stand a much greater chance of running into malice.
Would love to hear someone address that claim as I understood it.
If the connection is encrypted, then you have to trust the certificate authority, the browser and the service provider. If the connection is unencrypted, then in addition to the above, you have to trust that nobody is listening on that connection and that's a really tough pill to swallow, even if nothing bad happened to you in the past (just like with car accidents, it needs to happen only once to mess up your life).
If you don't think bad things happen all the time in the wild, see this story of Ashton Kutcher's Twitter account being hacked while attending TED: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/02/ashton-kutcher-twit...
Totally false claim. I would bet my ass that there is higher probability to have your traffic sniffed by tor exit nodes than by regular ISP's. At least for short-term malicious purposes, like email snooping and credit cards.
(For more long-term malicious purporses, NSA etc., you can't be really sure.)
Totally false claim. The biggest nodes on the tor network is run by established tor enthusiasts, and the largest portion of traffic is routed through them. Social pressure makes those people unlikely to put the node in jeopardy by sniffing exit traffic.
However, there is not much that would deter a coffee shop employee against sniffing the wi-fi, or for that matter, making them care to secure the router against would-be-attackers.
As such, I would be that there is a higher probability to have your traffic sniffed when visiting the local coffee shop, than by a tor exit nodes.
For example, while I visited the US it happened at 2 motels I stayed at for their network to insert ads in the web pages I was visiting. So they where not only snooping my traffic, but going further into altering it. Also, go to any conference or gathering of people, create an open Wifi hotspot (like, with your phone) and then enjoy all the cookies and passwords flowing through, from all the clueless people that connect to it.
Truth of the matter is, websites should be secure by default. Those that aren't represent a huge security risk. Fortunately many of the big ones are (e.g. GMail, Twitter, Facebook, etc...)
Also see:
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firesheep
[2] http://faceniff.ponury.net/