News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Keep Your Unsolicited Redesign to Yourself by derefr on Saturday August 24, 2013 @11:36PM (#6270798)
I think the main bit I could call "warped" was that, by the end of it, he's implying that 37signals should go make some free webpages for local businesses. Because, you know, since they're not True Professionals, they're novices, and since they're novices, they need things to fluff their resumes with.

Honestly, if the author had just left out any mention of the professional designers who redesign things for fun, in the "concept car" sort of way; and specifically targeted the article right from the beginning at only the amateurs who think that "this is the way to recognition", then sure, it'd be a fine article. I also would have skipped reading it, as I think would most of HN--thus the underhanded form of argumentation required to come around from a linkbait-y premise, to his actual point.

Re:Keep Your Unsolicited Redesign to Yourself by karjaluoto on Saturday August 24, 2013 @11:54PM (#6270841)
In no way did I imply that 37signals should make free webpages. (I'd never encourage a designer to work for free.) Instead, I was thinking back to when I first saw of unsolicited redesigns appear. My best recollection was when 37signals used this approach to generate visibility for their firm.