News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by KirinDave on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @01:35PM (#627059)
This effect has actually been observed for quite awhile. For some inexplicable reason, people associate Google with integrity and correctness. We've observed people get objectively better results from non-google sources and then say Google's was better. When asked why, they basically special plead the case for Google (e.g., "This isn't what I meant to search for but it's very interesting." is evidently a real excuse offered).

It's a very weird effect. Ignoring everything else, Google certainly wins at cultivating brand loyalty. They're up there with Apple's brand loyalty in that respect.

Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by mdasen on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @02:17PM (#627159)
There might also be another effect. Both Microsoft's search (under the MSN name) and Yahoo's existed before Google's. Google came along and really beat all the search engines that exited in terms of result quality. Microsoft and Yahoo have since upgraded their algorithms and gotten a lot better. However, people still associate the two as being the poor engines compared to Google's that they used to be. People's subjective evaluation of quality isn't just based on current results, but experiences they've had which might no longer apply due to changes in the product. There's no reason to include Yahoo search capabilities from 6 years ago in one's evaluation of Yahoo's results, but that's how people's minds operate.

I think that's why Microsoft desperately wants to rebrand their engine (over and over) so that people will think it's something new that they should evaluate for the first time rather than the pre-Google product that they found inferior to Google.

Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by patcito on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @08:14PM (#627759)
Yahoo first search engine was google embedded into yahoo. Before that, yahoo was just a searchable directory of websites. Later yahoo switched to their own search engine ouverture.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by pmjordan on Wednesday May 27, 2009 @03:39AM (#628164)
I'm pretty sure that was AltaVista, not Google.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by sp332 on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @01:40PM (#627071)
Every few months, when MS or Yahoo or Ask claim to have improved their results, or some little guy claims to have better (or more useful) results than Google, I actually go try them out. Google consistently has more-relevant results, closer to the top than anyone else I've tried. Their new "SearchWiki" lets me fix the dozen or so cases where Google doesn't have the exact result I was looking for.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by KirinDave on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @02:20PM (#627169)
Do you scientifically analyze the results? Do you ever try and remove your internal bias? Confirmation bias is a very strong effect in search engine result evaluations.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by jerf on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @02:39PM (#627215)
I do this: When Google fails me, I try the other search engines. So far, they fail me too.

Is this scientific? No. It is at least more objective, though. And I'm not trying for scientific rigor, just "does it do the task?" It's totally fair, too; that's how Google picked me up in the first place, and anyone else who meets that bar will get my business.

Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by endtime on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @05:20PM (#627540)
>I do this: When Google fails me, I try the other search engines. So far, they fail me too.

There's a case you're missing - that Google doesn't outright fail, but its performance is inferior to Yahoo's or Microsoft's. For example, Google may have the page you're looking for at the bottom of the first page of results (in which case you'd probably be satisfied and not try another search engine), but Yahoo or Microsoft might list it as the first result, which would be superior performance.

Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by sp332 on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @04:35PM (#627459)
It's just a search engine. It's not science.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by KirinDave on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @06:47PM (#627668)
That's not how anyone producing a search engine treats it. Data and feedback from users is rigorously analyzed in a statically consistent way that is as scientific as we can afford to make it.

Go do some mechanical turking for us, please. :)

Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by omouse on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @08:38PM (#627790)
When you're analyzing billions and billions of results and can produce a lot of data and can draw verifiable conclusions based on that data, I think it's safe to call it a science.

A search engine meant for use by billions of people is not a trivial thing.

Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by abossy on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @07:59PM (#627742)
It's information science.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by likpok on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @09:38PM (#627836)
It's like with Coke. People prefer Pepsi-flavored brown carbonated sugar liquid to Coke-flavored brown carbonated sugar liquid, but Coke to Pepsi.
Re:Users Love Microsoft, Yahoo Search -- When It's Branded W... by prakash on Tuesday May 26, 2009 @02:45PM (#627227)
Skrenta talks about this, "Brand Perception Gap": http://www.skrenta.com/2007/01/winnertakeall_google_and_the_...