This is really wrong, to get rid of the 20% low performers, you install a system that destroy everyone's confidence and promote short term decision making.
In the end, you get rid of 20% of people that just don't play the game AND you decrease the overall performance the group of people.
I remember reading a good article showing how rewards affect people performance by changing their goal, but I can't find it. Anyone?
Disclosure: I recently started in a full time position at Microsoft.
But how do you implement a global stack ranking in such a diverse company like Microsoft? There is no good criteria for comparing the kernel developers to the frontend programmers, for example. I doubt you could even find 100 employees working on the same kind of task.
People say stack ranking is bad within Microsoft because you're not ranked against all 50k+ employees but against 10+ people that report to the same manager.
If 2 out of 10 people are guaranteed low ranking, then it's better to be a mediocre programmer in a team of poor programmers than to be a very good programmer in a team of even better programmers.
It also means that it makes sense to sabotage the performance of your 9 colleagues because you only care about looking better than them, not about doing best possible job for the company or your team.
A global stack ranking, if it was actually possible, would be great. You do want to get rid of low performers (and hire better replacements) and in a large enough pool the bottom 20% will really be worth replacing with better people.