Re:The Universal Rules of Civilized Discourse
by pfortuny on Saturday August 24, 2013 @03:05PM
(#6269460)
We should morally evaluate what others say, certainly: as a matter of fact, that is what we do to have an opinion in ethical questions. I do not think I advocated the opposite. What I opposed was attacking the opponent, instead of the ideas.
Re:The Universal Rules of Civilized Discourse
by wissler on Saturday August 24, 2013 @06:03PM
(#6269964)
It's possible my criticism isn't aimed at you, but at those who get angry and start screaming "be polite" or "be tolerant of others" when their views are morally evaluated.
In any case, based on my experience they are at least fellow travelers, cowardly hiding behind "be polite" while suppressing rational dissent.
I see no reason why we should refrain from morally evaluating what others say, whether that evaluation be positive or negative. In fact, I think it leads to a great deal of evil to not so evaluate.