Re:The Universal Rules of Civilized Discourse
by gametheoretic on Friday August 23, 2013 @11:02PM
(#6267414)
In their own way, the comments are more interesting than the article. Atwood lists StormFront as one of the sites they investigated the dynamics of. The other two object; one claims Atwood was dismissive of his concerns in a twitter convo. In the end, the posts were civilized and the discourse, nonexistent. Each is visibly holding back his fuller opinion not b/c it would be uncivilized to give it but b/c he fears being seen as such. What was gained?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Universal Rules of Civilized Discourse
by mpyne on Friday August 23, 2013 @11:26PM
(#6267480)
I actually clicked on the Stormfront link, and felt stupid immediately afterward; as far as I could tell the only demand was that you were polite to other white persons. Certainly I didn't get a very strong "be nice to every poster" vibe.
Re:The Universal Rules of Civilized Discourse
by derleth on Saturday August 24, 2013 @01:28PM
(#6269205)
Stormfront is fairly notorious for being a racist forum, which is populated chiefly by racist whites (and those who wish to act like them) and run solely for the benefit of racist whites. It is a hateful place and its rules should be viewed with skepticism on that basis.
Re:The Universal Rules of Civilized Discourse
by batemanesque on Saturday August 24, 2013 @10:23AM
(#6268718)
exactly. I find it problematic that they seem to think calling someone names is completely impermissible but citing a white supremacist forum's guidelines is not.