"If a platform has to work this hard to define and explain what it is, it might not be that great of a platform."
Reminds me of the first years of twitter. People either loved it or hated it. But, almost no one understood it.
"What genuine advantage does Medium offer regular, non-hyper-connected authors"
About 100 first readers. I guess that depends on the channels you post on. I only made 3 posts all in "what I learned building" collection.
Still unsold: Why is Medium better for individual expression than starting your own blog?
Further: If SEO is doing what it should do, why should I care how my articles are arranged on my own site? What genuine advantage does Medium offer regular, non-hyper-connected authors (especially in it's current, invite-only publishing state)?