Re:US court rules masking IP address to access blocked Websi...
by baddox on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:06PM
(#6265235)
A request was made for a resource on a server, and that server fulfilled the request. There was no access "against the will" of the server. If the owner of the server configured the server incorrectly, I don't see why the client should be legally liable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US court rules masking IP address to access blocked Websi...
by bmelton on Monday August 26, 2013 @10:19AM
(#6277183)
A cease and desist order from the company that owns the server pretty effectively illustrates that it is indeed "against the will" of the server's owners. I'll wholly concede that the server itself doesn't have a will of its own, but otherwise, server configuration is not of any legal concern.
It's worth noting that this is different than just misconfiguration hacks, where somebody gains access to something completely private because the server allowed it. I agree that in those circumstances, no culpability should be found on the part of the 'hacker'. However, in this case, Amazon said "Hey you. What you're doing? Stop it."
Moreover, they did so with a letter written by their attorneys. Not legally binding, sure, but at the same time, a pretty clear illustration that the access wasn't wanted.