Edit: I stand corrected the British security is mostly Heathrow. I flew from Edimburgh this April and the security was mostly the same as the rest of europe. Also I have improved the wording a bit.
Schiphol was still 30+ minutes (was in line behind a flight from...Iran), but not incredibly annoying like London was.
http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2012/04/immigration-...
I don't know if they've fixed the problem, but its permanently soured me on flying into England.
I am British — which helps somewhat — but I've known them to throw us on the back of the "All Passports" queue when it's been relatively busy, and never noticed it take any longer than otherwise. That all said, I more often than not pass through the passport control used for domestic transfers, rather than that for leaving the airport (though my experience is that that tends to have shorter queues than the one for transfers).
And no, I wouldn't expect being from the US to help, except for not requiring a visa.
That's a pretty nuanced decision for the inspector to make. Polygraph machines and their operators routinely mess that one up.
I doubt that they themselves claim they can make that differentiation, and if they do so make that claim, I'd bet cash on it that it has been untested as far as accuracy regarding false positives.
Generally speaking, teaching 'technique' to a layman and expecting them to all be of equal caliber is just simply wrong.
The real difference is that it's only one airport. It would be very expensive and time-consuming to scale that up to secure every airport in the US.
Not much news about false positives for them makes it out, at least not in English-language media, but the worst I've heard of them doing is grilling suspicious people for a few hours.
The important bits are whether the difference is detectable in a manner that is convenient (putting each passenger through an MRI machine is out of the question), reliable (minimize false positives and false negatives), and so on. Just saying "there's a difference" adds no new information to the conversation unless you're able to expand on the quantifiable aspects of those differences.