News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by lukeqsee on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:33PM (#6258575)
Most striking and appalling is the lack of common sense and basic empathy throughout this whole ordeal. For example, he asked multiple times for water, a basic necessity for life, and was denied multiple times. That can't be rationalized in anyway—what did they expect, him to drown someone? His requests as to the nature of his detention were denied. His rights to privacy were utterly ignored. And it goes on…

We need to wake up and see that those that "protect" our safety have reduced us to a state of fear worse than that which we are trying to prevent. We are now being terrorized by our own terrorism prevention. Merely because we happened to clean for bed-bugs and look Middle Eastern.

When will we say enough is enough and do something about it?

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by eshvk on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:42PM (#6258651)
The most popular argument against the TSA that I have heard? They spend too much of their time searching the "wrong people". You know the kind that wouldn't "hurt a fly"? Weasel phrases that in essence mean that the TSA should do what Israel does. Racial profiling. Not that they don't do enough of it. At least on paper, they try to mess up that by searching white grandmas from the midwest and little blonde girls. Of course, the latter is what America complains the most about really.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by bayesianhorse on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:50PM (#6258716)
I admit, the TSA in this case didn't do racial profiling. They skipped that step, and went straight on to "rabid racism".

That they apparently had no idea what a Hindu is doesn't make it one bit better.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by JshWright on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:11PM (#6258891)
Did you miss the fact that he triggered the explosive residue detector several times?

As the article itself describes... when he skipped the pat-down (and therefore skipped the ERD), no one batted an eye at his race.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by ferdo on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:19PM (#6258940)
Correction: they claimed he triggered the detector.

It's not a wise course to take government employees at their word.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by JshWright on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:22PM (#6258964)
'They' also claim the contrails from airliners aren't spreading mind control agents...
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by ferdo on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:29PM (#6259025)
I have proof and past experience with dishonest government employees. Please take your arguments for chemtrails elsewhere.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by JshWright on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:49PM (#6259181)
Sure, but what you're talking about is widespread conspiracy to allow ERDs to be 'triggered' manually.

I think that theory warrants about as much consideration as chemtrails.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by 67726e on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:54PM (#6259226)
He never said they manually triggered an alarm. He said they could very well be lying that a detector was ever used let alone registered explosives.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by JshWright on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:01PM (#6259281)
That would be extremely gutsy on the part of the TSA employee... I go through the pat-down dance at least once a month, and that test is always done while I'm standing there, and the pass/fail reports are quite obvious (big green/red boxes with text).
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by 67726e on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:56PM (#6259638)
Is that dependent on the airport? I've flown as recently as two months ago, and I went through four pat-downs over the course of the trip. I never saw any green/red indicator when they tested the pat-down gloves.

Regardles, I wouldn't exactly put it past the TSA to make up a positive hit. It's not like we haven't ever had a police officer claim someone committed a traffic violation on someone based on appearance and ultimately find drugs or some other criminal behavior.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by JshWright on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:04PM (#6259688)
Perhaps.

In the past two months, I've had pat-downs in DCA, BWI, and PHI (my home airport, SYR, doesn't have scanners, so there's nothing to opt out of).

They all use machines similar to this one:

http://www.tsa.gov/sites/default/files/images/edt_closeup.jp...

I've never seen a failure myself (the green bar you see pops up after a few seconds), but according to a friend who has, a red bar pops up instead.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by bayesianhorse on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:53PM (#6259215)
Even if the chemical detector did trigger an alarm: These devices are not faultproof, and if you can't find an explosive, can't find surgical scars, can't find anything in the baggage, you could safely assume the passenger does not have any explosives on or in himself.

The only explanation that makes more sense if the TSA, NSA or FBI had warnings about very cleverly implanted explosive devices and want to keep that knowledge hidden. That would explain why the pat-downs didn't convince them (maybe they tried to evoke a pain response), why they didn't give him anything to eat or drink, and why the JetBlue representative didn't want him to fly on this day, but was fine with the next day...

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by mistercow on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:29PM (#6259017)
So it's OK to be racist if you have another reason to be suspicious?
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by JshWright on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:48PM (#6259166)
I don't think that's what I said...

I think it's more than a little hyperbolic to describe their actions as 'rabid racism'

They had a legitimate reason for suspicion. That reason wasn't the color of his skin, it was the color of a computer screen (a screen that flashes green hundreds of times a day flashed red in this case).

It's quite obvious that much ignorance and xenophobia followed, but I don't think it crossed (laughably subjective) line of 'rabid.'

A friend of mine who is about as 'all American' looking as you can get (white, tall, former marine...) tripped the same alarms after he had been firing a gun at a range the day before. He had an obvious and clear explanation for the alarm, so his experience wasn't as invasive, but they certainly gave him a hard time about it.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by mistercow on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:47PM (#6259582)
>It's quite obvious that much ignorance and xenophobia followed, but I don't think it crossed (laughably subjective) line of 'rabid.'

I suppose we could get into definitions of racism here. We're likely talking about "institutional racism", for which "prejudice plus power" is a pretty good definition, but I think perhaps "prejudice multiplied by power" might be even more apt. The prejudice was clearly considerable, but the power, and how it interacted with that prejudice, is what raises it to the level that I think could be called "rabid".

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by astrobe_ on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:10PM (#6260107)
Seriously, you cannot support that level of incompetency. How many people pass airport gates everyday? How many people are caught with explosives everyday? The second pat-down should have been enough to decide that the machine was triggered by some chemical not directly related to explosives, as they were enable to find any bomb anywhere. Worse, it is very clear in the story that they know it can happen.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by lukeqsee on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:45PM (#6258671)
I've heard the same arguments. Sadly, I have no good answer for how the TSA should do their job. However, treating someone rudely and, to an extent, inhumanly, doesn't fit the bill.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by eshvk on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:51PM (#6258720)
The point to realize that America is not fucking Israel. We are not under threat the way Israel is. That is a country that is struggling for its existence; in missile range from Iran; surrounded by hostile forces on all sides.

In America, things are different. Sure the borders are porous; sure there is a low probability that the muslim guy down the street is a terrorist, sure there is a possibility that the war of 1812 could be repeated by the Canadians.

However, is the country really going to live its life based on insignificant probabilities? It has been 12+ years since 9/11. Surely, there is a time limit after which this insanity can mellow down.

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by seehafer on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:50PM (#6258714)
Israeli-style random questioning in all airports, conducted by highly-trained experts (not rent-a-cops), in conjunction with profiling.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by tsax on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:55PM (#6259235)
Problem is affirmative action rentacops that the TSA has become. Israeli security personnel are highly trained, intelligent folks. The ethnic profile of such a TSA would be > 90% white. Cry racism, and there goes your competent force.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by unhappyhippie on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:09PM (#6259726)
As someone who has had a harrowing experience at an Israeli airport, I would dispute the claim that they are highly trained or even intelligent. I don't even want to recount my experience at Tel Aviv, its much milder than OP's but it spoils my mood just thinking about it.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by seehafer on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:12PM (#6259374)
I'm not an expert, but I doubt if you pulled from FBI agents, CIA operatives, Special Forces, etc. that the ethnic profile would be > 90% white.
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by tsax on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:07PM (#6259704)
Competence in pattern detection is pretty much an IQ test. When you go higher on the scale, the number of non-whites, non-asians, and non-jews drops precipitously. I wouldn't bet my house on this prediction, but I would bet a few hundred $. For one, maybe the competence required is not that high. But you are surely wrong about Special Forces. They are overwhelmingly white. See here: http://e-ring.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2013/05/10/budget_watc...
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by pstuart on Thursday August 22, 2013 @02:17PM (#6258927)
> Sadly, I have no good answer for how the TSA should do their job

Shouldn't we be "profiling" based on assessed risk? And isn't the NSA making those assessments? It should be a simple as submitting the user's identity and circumstances and getting a guided response back: "no likely threat", "detain immediately", etc.

Not that I'm a fan of the NSA, but isn't that what they are ostensibly there for?

Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by cenhyperion on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:30PM (#6259861)
You're honestly advocating more racial profiling and propelling us towards the state of racism, hatred, and paranoia of Israel? Really?
Re:Don't Fly During Ramadan by clamprecht on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:51PM (#6258724)
> When will we say enough is enough and do something about it?

Sadly, much later than most people think. Look at how long things have gone on in history, before people realized how bad it really was. In hindsight, it's easy, but when everyone just seems to be accepting it, it's not so easy. E.g. Germany in the 1930s.