Re:October 3, 2011 FISC Opinion Holding NSA Surveillance Unc...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:46PM
(#6253200)
Yeah, I think the major revelation here is that the Administration clearly had a pattern of withholding and misrepresenting what was doing in order to get the FISC to approve it. Aside from the obvious negative aspects, there is a minor positive aspect here: clearly, the court wasn't seen as a "rubber stamp".
And this clearly takes the program out of the realm of honest attempts to protect security within the law where perhaps there are disagreements, major or minor, about the boundaries; a regular pattern of misrepresentation to the court overseeing surveillance erases any grounds to claim that the surveillance effort did not involve deliberate, conscious illegality and deliberate, conscious efforts to conceal that illegality.
And this clearly takes the program out of the realm of honest attempts to protect security within the law where perhaps there are disagreements, major or minor, about the boundaries; a regular pattern of misrepresentation to the court overseeing surveillance erases any grounds to claim that the surveillance effort did not involve deliberate, conscious illegality and deliberate, conscious efforts to conceal that illegality.